The headlines sure looked great. A $285 million settlement sounds like a lot of money, but it falls well short of what the giant corporate criminal, Citigroup, would even consider nuisance, let alone painful. And while it does make good on investors’ losses, there are many others, who were damaged, by Citigroup’s crime, left out in the cold.
As the housing market began its collapse, Wall Street firms and sophisticated investors searched for ways to profit. Some of them found an easy method: Stuff a portfolio with risky mortgage-related investments, sell it to unsuspecting customers and bet against it.
Citigroup on Wednesday agreed to pay $285 million to settle a civil complaint by the Securities and Exchange Commission that it had defrauded investors who bought just such a deal. The transaction involved a $1 billion portfolio of mortgage-related investments, many of which were handpicked for the portfolio by Citigroup without telling investors of its role or that it had made bets that the investments would fall in value.
In the four years since the housing market began its steady descent, securities regulators have settled only two cases related to the financial crisis for a larger sum of money. This is also the third case brought by the S.E.C. accusing a major Wall Street institution of misleading customers about who was putting together a security and about their motive. Goldman Sachs and JPMorgan Chase & Company both settled similar cases last year.
The settlement will refund investors with interest and include a $95 million fine — a relative pittance for a giant like Citigroup. On Monday, the company reported that in the third quarter alone it earned profits of $3.8 billion on revenue of $20.8 billion. The settlement may also have trouble getting approval from Jed S. Rakoff, the federal district judge in New York who must ultimately sign off on the fine and who has taken a hard line on S.E.C. settlements… [emphasis added]
Inserted from <NY Times>
I have no doubt that this settlement is good for the investors Citigroup defrauded, and that some of them are truly needy, pensioners, and the like. Most, however, are probably wealthy investors and speculators, so once again, the well to do get the bail out, while the 99% twist in the wind. This settlement does nothing to help the victims of ninja loans who lost their homes, the people who faithfully paid their mortgages, while foreclosures in their neighborhoods sucked the value from their homes, or the millions hurt by the recession that the collapse of the real estate market engendered, people that lost jobs and small businesses.
Judge Rakoff, could nix the deal. He has an excellent record on the bench, because he was appointed by a Democrat. Rakoff rejected a similar settlement with Merrill Lynch. I hope he does here too, because a mere $95 million fine will only encourage Banksters to do it again. I’d like to see what kind of punitive damages a jury would assign.
As the housing market began its collapse, Wall Street firms and sophisticated investors searched for ways to profit. Some of them found an easy method: Stuff a portfolio with risky mortgage-related investments, sell it to unsuspecting customers and bet against it. 
My introduction to activism came not from the peace movement, but from the civil rights movement. I felt so shamed by my father’s overt racism that during my simmer vacation in 1963, at fifteen years of age, I headed south to Alabama for a month of protesting. It was there that I first saw Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. The people were very caring toward me, and more than once, prevented me from getting myself killed or maimed by police, dogs, fire hoses and angry racists. I wasn’t that brave, but stupid, thinking I was bullet proof, like so many kids of that age. From there, I traveled to Washington, DC and was on the mall when King delivered his “I Have a Dream” speech. In April, 1967, I was at Riverside Church for King’s “Beyond Vietnam” speech, and met with him afterward, because I was on the committee organizing Vietnam Summer. I met with Dr. King half a dozen times, always in a group, and only spoke with him one-on-one on a couple brief occasions, but he had a profound influence on me. He taught me to persevere, that worthwhile accomplishments take time. He taught me that faith does not have to be ugly. He taught me that non-violence is the only path to lasting reform. No monument can do justice to this giant of a man. Barack Obama gave the keynote speech. Here it is followed by “I have a Dream” and “Beyond Vietnam ”.
For the record, we on “the left” do not attack Justice Thomas for any reason other than the fact that he is a terrible judge. His record on the Supreme Court is marred by
Linking up with the Occupy Wall Street protests that began in New York, tens of thousands of people around the world took to the streets Saturday to reiterate their anger at the global financial system, corporate greed and government cutbacks.
The U.S. is abandoning plans to keep U.S. troops in Iraq past a year-end withdrawal deadline, The Associated Press has learned. The decision to pull out fully by January will effectively end more than eight years of U.S. involvement in the Iraq war, despite ongoing concerns about its security forces and the potential for instability.
The Congressional Progressive Caucus (CPC) today sent policy proposals to Senator Patty Murray and Congressman Jeb Hensarling, Co-Chairs of the Joint Select Committee on Deficit Reduction, recommending that the work of the committee focus on creating jobs, raising revenues through fair taxation and protecting Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security. The CPC identified more than $4 trillion in savings, which would increase to more than $7 trillion if the Bush tax cuts are allowed to expire on schedule. The recommendations direct the savings toward job creation, the single most important means to reduce the deficit.