Outside the Box on Big Oil

 Posted by at 2:18 am  Politics
May 152010
 

Of late, we have been so focused on the Gulf oil leak that other oil industry atrocities have slipped under the radar.  Bill Moyers wrote this excellent piece on one of them.  I’m so glad to see that continues to share the benefits of his integrity, intellect and experience despite his retirement.

texaco-oil-fire Even as headlines and broadcast news are dominated by BP’s fire-ravaged, sunken offshore rig and the ruptured well gushing a reported 210,000 gallons of oil per day into the Gulf of Mexico, there’s another important story involving Big Oil and pollution — one that shatters not only the environment but the essential First Amendment right of journalists to tell truth and shame the devil.

(Have you read, by the way, that after the surviving, dazed and frightened workers were evacuated from that burning platform, they were met by lawyers from the drilling giant Transocean with forms to sign stating they had not been injured and had no first-hand knowledge of what had happened?! So much for the corporate soul.)

But our story is about another petrochemical giant — Chevron — and a major threat to independent journalism. In New York last Thursday, Federal Judge Lewis A. Kaplan ordered documentary producer and director Joe Berlinger to turn over to Chevron more than 600 hours of raw footage used to create a film titled Crude: The Real Price of Oil.

Released last year, it’s the story of how 30,000 Ecuadorians rose up to challenge the pollution of their bodies, livestock, rivers and wells from Texaco’s drilling for oil there, a rainforest disaster that has been described as the Amazon’s Chernobyl. When Chevron acquired Texaco in 2001 and attempted to dismiss claims that it was now responsible, the indigenous people and their lawyers fought back in court.

Some of the issues and nuances of Berlinger’s case are admittedly complex, but they all boil down to this: Chevron is trying to avoid responsibility and hopes to find in the unused footage — material the filmmaker did not utilize in the final version of his documentary — evidence helpful to the company in fending off potential damages of $27.3 billion.

This is a serious matter for reporters, filmmakers and frankly, everyone else. Tough, investigative reporting without fear or favor — already under siege by severe cutbacks and the shutdown of newspapers and other media outlets — is vital to the public awareness and understanding essential to a democracy. As Michael Moore put it, “The chilling effect of this is, [to] someone like me, if something like this is upheld, the next whistleblower at the next corporation is going to think twice about showing me some documents if that information has to be turned over to the corporation that they’re working for.”

In an open letter on Joe Berlinger’s behalf, signed by many in the non-fiction film business (including the two of us), the Independent Documentary Association described Chevron’s case as a “fishing expedition” and wrote that, “At the heart of journalism lies the trust between the interviewer and his or her subject. Individuals who agree to be interviewed by the news media are often putting themselves at great risk, especially in the case of television news and documentary film where the subject’s identity and voice are presented in the final report.

“If witnesses sense that their entire interviews will be scrutinized by attorneys and examined in courtrooms they will undoubtedly speak less freely. This ruling surely will have a crippling effect on the work of investigative journalists everywhere, should it stand.”

Just so. With certain exceptions, the courts have considered outtakes of a film to be the equivalent of a reporter’s notebook, to be shielded from the scrutiny of others. If we — reporters, journalists, filmmakers — are required to turn research, transcripts and outtakes over to a government or a corporation — or to one party in a lawsuit — the whole integrity of the process of journalism is in jeopardy; no one will talk to us.

In his decision, Judge Kaplan wrote that, “Review of Berlinger’s outtakes will contribute to the goal of seeing not only that justice is done, but that it appears to be done.” He also quoted former Supreme Court Justice Louis D. Brandeis’ famous maxim that “sunlight is said to be the best of disinfectants.”

There is an irony to this, noted by Frank Smyth of the Committee to Protect Journalists.Brandeis “made his famous sunlight statement about the need to expose bankers and investors who controlled ‘money trusts’ to stifle competition, and he later railed against not only powerful corporations but the lawyers and other members of the bar who worked to perpetuate their power”

In a 1905 speech before the Harvard Ethical Society, Brandeis said, “Instead of holding a position of independence, between the wealthy and the people, prepared to curb the excesses of either, able lawyers have, to a large extent, allowed themselves to become adjuncts of great corporations and have neglected the obligation to use their powers for the protection of the people.”

Now, more than a century later, Chevron, the third largest corporation in America, according to Forbes Magazine, has hauled out their lawyers in a case that would undermine the right of journalists to protect the people by telling them the truth… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <Huffington Post>

I agree with Moyers completely.  I can understand judges requiring the same materials to review themselves in the privacy of their chambers under strict secrecy.  In this way, the defendants are afforded protections from creative editing of the type that occurred in the ACORN case.  But revealing whistleblowers will shut them up tighter then a Republican Senator’s grip on a nickel for the poor.

This piece reveals how Machiavellian Big Oil has become, and in that respect it dovetails nicely with a Rachel Maddow report on the lengths to which Big Oil will go to evade taxes, regulation, and responsibility.

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

Honesty in Big Oil is as common as Muslim Popes in Catholicism.  Whatever it takes, they all need to pay the full cost of producing their product, including all the suffering they inflict on humankind and nature alike.  There are ways.  A 90% excise tax, perhaps?

Corporations are NOT people!  Money is NOT speech!

Share

Obama Rips GOP

 Posted by at 2:17 am  Politics
May 152010
 

If you haven’t seen this clip, you’ll love it!

obama_hcr_speech President Barack Obama is ripping into his Republican opponents, accusing them of refusing to help rebuild America after having "created the mess" and driving the economy "into the ditch."

Obama told a Democratic fundraising event in New York late Thursday that despite one of the busiest and most accomplished legislative sessions in recent memory, he witnessed "our friends on the other side of the aisle fall all over themselves to argue otherwise."

"You would have thought at a time of historic crisis that Republican leaders would have been more willing to help us find a way out of this mess — particularly since they created the mess," Obama said.

"We all have a stake in cleaning it up. We’re not Democrats or Republicans first — we’re Americans first."

The president met with Democratic supporters after traveling to the industrial city of Buffalo, New York to assure Americans that the US economy was "heading in the right direction" after official data showed new claims for unemployment benefits fell for the fourth week in a row… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <Raw Story>

And here’s the video:

Thumbs up!

Share

GOP Sides with Big Oil

 Posted by at 2:36 am  Politics
May 142010
 

Thanks, Diane, for sending me this.  By the time I saw it, it was all over the news.

Ugly, isn’t it?

BP probably held it back, because analysis of the video reveals that the leak is over 70,000 barrels a day.  The original estimate from the Coast Guard, based on BP data was 5,000 barrels per day.  So what we have is one Exxon Valdez disaster every four days.

Democrats in the Senate are trying to raise the liability cap from $75 million to $10 billion.  That’s still too low.  BP annual profit is double that.  The only cap for a disaster of this magnitude is $infinity.  But even the overly lax cap of $10 billion is too much for the GOP.

Murkowski-Palin Alaska’s senior senator blocked legislation Thursday that would have dramatically increased liability caps on oil companies, in the wake of one of the industry’s biggest disasters.

Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-Alaska) objected to a voice vote request by Sen. Robert Menendez (D-N.J.) on the bill, which would have spiked the maximum liability for oil companies after an oil spill from $75 million to $10 billion. The legislation has significant support from Democrats, and the White House has indicated it backs an increase in liability caps.

But Murkowski said the legislation is “not where we need to be right now” and would unfairly advantage large oil companies by pricing the small companies out of the market. Murkowski did signal that she would be open to "look at the liability cap and consider raising it.” Just not at this moment.

Menendez, speaking to reporters after the bill was halted on the Senate floor, said the opposition indicates that Republicans are on the side of the oil companies, not the American people. There had been no formal floor debate or roll call vote requested on the legislation.

“It’s straightforward, it’s common sense,” Menendez said. “Either you want to fully protect the small businesses, individuals and communities devastated by a man-made disaster — this is not a natural disaster; this is a man-made disaster — or you want to protect multibillion-dollar oil companies from being held fully accountable. Apparently there are some in the Senate who prefer to protect the oil companies.”… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <Politico>

Murkowski offered two main arguments.  First is that Big Oil has unlimited liability already, because anyone can sue them.  Tell that to the victims of Exxon Valdez spill.  After twenty years, many have died of old age waiting to see the first penny.  The people whose livelihoods are gone need justice now, not 20-30 years from now… if the live that long.

Second, Murkowski argued that it would put “mom and pop” operators out of business by making the cost of their liability insurance so high that they could not afford to operate.  Earth to Murkowski!  Is anyone home?  There are no mom and pop companies in deep offshore drilling.  If there were, any company that cannot afford liability for the damage they cause has no business being in business.  If I can’t afford auto liability insurance, I have no business driving a car.

Many in the GOP are shaking their heads in mock shock that one lone Senator could do such a thing.  Don’t you dare believe that!  Theses greedy Republicans goose step in lock step.  Murkowski was assigned this role, because she does not face reelection until 2014.  The GOP is seeking to help Big Oil avoid responsibility without appearing to do so.

Corporations are NOT people!  Money is NOT speech!

Share

An Oregonian Leads the Way

 Posted by at 2:34 am  Politics
May 142010
 

Corporations are NOT people!  Money is NOT speech!

KurtSchraeder

Oregon Representative Kurt Schraeder has introduced a Constitutional Amendment to Counter the criminal Citizens United decision by the Extreme Court.  It addresses the second half of my mantra.

…

Article

Section 1. The Congress shall have power to prohibit, limit, and otherwise regulate the contribution of funds or donation of in-kind equivalents to candidates standing for election to a federal office in the United States and to prohibit, limit, and otherwise regulate the expenditure of funds or donation of in-kind equivalents used to support or purchase media advertisements intended to influence the outcome of an election for federal office in the United States.

Whenever Congress should exercise such power, it must apply equally and uniformly to all individual persons recognized as citizens of the United States.

Whenever Congress should exercise such power on associations of citizens of the United States, it must apply equally and uniformly to all associations of citizens of the United States.

Section 2. Each of the several States shall have power to prohibit, limit, and otherwise regulate the contribution of funds or donation of in-kind equivalents to candidates standing for election to public office in the State and to prohibit, limit, and otherwise regulate expenditure of funds or donation of in-kind equivalents used to support or purchase media advertisements intended to influence the outcome of an election for public office or plebiscite in the State.

Whenever a State should exercise such power, it must apply equally and uniformly to all individual persons recognized as citizens of the State.

Whenever a State should exercise such power on associations of citizens of the State, it must apply equally and uniformly to all associations of citizens of the State.

Section 3. No person who is not a citizen of the United States, association of persons not citizens of the United States, foreign governments, or persons acting as agents thereof may contribute funds or donate in-kind equivalents to candidates standing for election to public office in the United States or otherwise expend funds or donate in-kind equivalents in a manner intended to influence the outcome an election for public office or plebiscite in the United States.

The Congress shall have exclusive power to enforce this section by appropriate legislation.

Section 4. Congress shall have the power to enforce this article by appropriate legislation. [emphasis original]

Inserted from <Blue Oregon>

I do not expect this to be ratified, but it does define the issue and serves to help separate progressives from pigs.  Bravo!

Share
May 132010
 

That link from Diane is a gift that keeps giving.  Here’s an analysis of what went wrong.

Gulf_Oil_Spill Bad wiring and a leak in what’s supposed to be a "blowout preventer." Sealing problems that may have allowed a methane eruption. Even a dead battery, of all things.

New disclosures Wednesday revealed a complex cascade of deep-sea equipment failures and procedural problems in the oil rig explosion and massive spill that is still fouling the waters of the Gulf of Mexico and threatening industries and wildlife near the coast and on shore.

The public also got its first look on Wednesday of oil gushing from the broken pipe that rests nearly a mile under water as BP PLC, the well’s operator, released a video taken by a remotely controlled camera. Oil flowing from a break in the yellowish pipe becomes lighter in color as it mixes with natural gas. Over the past 21 days more than 4 million gallons of oil have been released.

A litany of worrisome events and findings that were at play on the night of the well explosion and pipe rupture was described in internal corporate documents, marked confidential but provided to a House committee by BP and by the manufacturer of the safety device. Lawmakers released them at a House hearing.

A senior BP executive, Lamar McKay, cautioned, "It’s inappropriate to draw any conclusions before all the facts are known." But the documents established the firmest evidence to date of the sequence of catastrophic events that led to the explosion and worsening spill, a series of failures more reminiscent of the loss of the space shuttle Challenger than the wreck of the Exxon Valdez.

Like the 1986 Challenger disaster, the investigation into the Gulf spill may well show that complex and seemingly failproof technical systems went wrong because of overlooked problems that interacted with each other in unexpected ways. In the 1989 Exxon Valdez disaster, a captain simply ran his ship onto a reef in Alaska’s Prince William Sound, spilling nearly 11 million gallons of oil.

The April 20 BP rig explosion 40 miles off the Louisiana coast killed 11 people. Oil continuing to flow into Gulf waters threatens sensitive ecological marshes and wetlands and the region’s fishing industry.

Congressional investigators revealed Wednesday that a key safety system, known as the blowout preventer, used in BP’s oil-drilling rig in the Gulf had a hydraulic leak and a failed battery that probably prevented it from working as designed.

They said that BP documents and others also indicated conflicting pipe pressure tests should have warned those on the rig that poor pipe integrity may have been allowing explosive methane gas to leak into the well.

"Significant pressure discrepancies were observed in at least two of these tests, which were conducted just hours before the explosion," said Rep. Henry Waxman, D-Calif., at a House hearing on the rig fire and oil leak, citing documents his committee had received from BP.

Asked about the tests, Steven Newman, president of Transocean, which owned the drilling rig, and Lamar McKay, president of BP America told the committee the pressure readings were worrisome.

They indicated "that there was something happening in the well bore that shouldn’t be happening," said Newman. McKay said the issue "is critical in the investigation" into the cause of the accident.

The well explosion unleashed a massive oil spill that after three weeks remains uncontained.

But Waxman said important elements of what went wrong were beginning to surface.

While "we have far more questions than answers," it appears clear that there were problems with the blowout preventers before the accident and confusion almost right up to the time of the explosion over the success of a process in which cement is injected into the well to temporarily close it in anticipation of future production… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <The Bay Ledger>

To clarify, the purpose of the pressure testing was to affirm the integrity of the cementing operation Halliburton had just performed.  Here’s Keith Olbermann with more:

 

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

I won’t comment on the Lieberman-Kerry Bill here, because two I posted an Action Alert to oppose it two pieces down.

Keith reported that the rig workers did not know a blowout preventer had been modified and because the modification did not show in their engineering documents, but did not say why.  I revealed  that BP was falsifying their engineering reports on May 4, nine days ago.  Two days ago, I posted that all the companies are pointing fingers at each other.  All the finger pointers are right.

One more thing.  The chemicals that BP is pumping into the gulf to disperse the spill are lethal to coral.  The loss of Florida’s reef system, one of the most diverse habitats in the world.  Its loss would be an unprecedented ecological disaster, not to mention that many of our most advanced medicines are harvested there and available nowhere else.

Corporations are NOT people!  Money is NOT speech!

Share
May 132010
 

Just when I thought that the GOP might get just a little cautious over their ongoing multiple sex scandals, Michael Steele, the gift that keeps giving, has done it again.

steele-tampa Man, the comedy keeps writing itself:

Breaking news on Twitter from Politico’s Mike Allen — the 2012 Republican National Convention will be held in Tampa.

Florida has been a fiercely contested “swing state” in recent presidential campaigns, and Barack Obama’s victory there in 20[08] was the Democratic Party’s first since 1996.

The Politico is right–Florida is a critical “swing” state. There are some high visibility and politically strained battles going on there (I’m looking at you two, Crist and Rubio). But somehow I suspect that there was another element factored in to the choice of Tampa:

A reputation can sometimes be hard to shake and the city of Tampa has a reputation it would probably like to eliminate. For the past decade some have called Tampa the lap dance capital of the world.

Paul Allen, the founder and publisher of NightMoves magazine, says he hears about the city’s reputation all the time. He believes the shear number of strip clubs in the Bay area has undoubtedly contributed to the city’s rep.

“In greater Tampa Bay, I think the last count is around 56 different clubs that are adult-oriented,” he said.

Another reason for the reputation is the city’s role in the adult industry. “If you own a club in Oshkosh, Wisconsin and you want to book a feature (dancer) to come to your club, there’s basically four people you can call. Three of those four companies are based right here in Tampa,” Allen said

… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <Crooks and Liars>

When I lived in Phoenix, I had a good friend who worked as a high-end call girl.  I knew her platonically only.  😥

Once she explained to me that, whenever a Republican or a religious right convention was in town, the local girls imported more girls from Las Vegas, because the demand exceeded the local girls’ ability to meet it.

We can be sure that there are going to be a bunch of exhausted lap dancers in Tampa.

I think local bloggers would be well served to position themselves outside Tampa’s kinkiest strip clubs, with cameras, during the convention.

GOP family values only apply when they are telling everyone else what to do.

Share
May 132010
 

I would expect this from Traitor Joe, but Kerry should hang his head in shame!

earthegg In the midst of what appears to be the worst offshore oil disaster in American history, U.S. Senators John Kerry (D-Mass.) and Joseph Lieberman (I-Conn.) will today put forth a draft climate bill that will not solve the problems of global warming and continues pandering to the fossil fuel industry — including expanded offshore oil drilling — that created the problems in the first place.

The proposal, leaked one day before its official release, reflects months of back-room negotiations between the senators, major polluters, and other Washington insiders, and would:

  • provide only a fraction of the greenhouse gas pollution reductions scientists have said are necessary to avoid catastrophic climate disruption;
  • ban successful Clean Air Act programs from reducing greenhouse pollution;
  • ban existing state and local efforts to tackle climate change;
  • catalyze increased oil and gas drilling — including offshore drilling; and
  • subsidize dangerous and costly nuclear energy.

In response, Center for Biological Diversity Executive Director Kierán Suckling urged rejection of the proposal unless these problems are addressed. He issued the following statement:

"The climate proposal put forth today by Senators Kerry and Lieberman represents a disaster for our climate and planet. This proposal moves us one baby step forward and at least three giant steps back in any rational effort to address the climate crisis.

"The senators’ proposal would entrench our addiction to fossil fuels by offering incentives for increased oil and gas drilling just days after what appears to be the worst offshore oil disaster in American history. Large domes, small domes, golf balls, garbage, chemical dispersants, fire — none have succeeded in stopping the enormous flow of oil into the Gulf of Mexico. Clearly, there are no ‘safeguards’ Senators Lieberman and Kerry could put into this bill to make offshore oil safe… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <Common Dreams>

If you’ve been reading awhile, you know that I am not an absolute thinker.  I see shades of gray and am often willing to accept a ‘the best we can get’ compromise over nothing at all, often to the chagrin of some of my more purist friends.  This is not one of those times.  There is no gray here.  There is black and deeper black.  This bill, unless drastically modified through the amendment process, leaves us worse off that the already unacceptable status quo.  I urge it’s defeat

You can contact your Senators here.

Share
May 122010
 

The giant telecom companies aren’t going to quietly give up their plans to control what you are allowed to see and hear.

netneutrality Net neutrality, a guiding principle for preserving a free and fair Internet, means that Internet service providers are not allowed to discriminate based on content for its customers. However, telecommunications firms — like AT&T, Verizon, Comcast and others — are firmly against net neutrality because they would like to increase their profits by deciding which websites customers can see, and at what speed. The telecom industry has dumped hundreds of millions of dollars into a lobby campaign against net neutrality. As the FCC now takes up net neutrality rule making, the industry is pushing an “outside approach” of hiring front groups and astroturf operatives.

This morning, representatives from various front groups launched a new coordinated campaign to kill net neutrality. Speaking on Capitol Hill, these front groups took turns decrying the evils of the principle of a fair and unbiased Internet. LULAC, which is funded by AT&T, called Net Neutrality “Obamacare for the Internet.” Americans for Prosperity — a corporate front group founded by oil billionaire David Koch but also funded by telecom interests — unveiled a new ad smearing net neutrality as a “government takeover” (the initial ad buy is $1.4 million [corprocon delinked] dollars). And Grover Norquist, representing his “Americans for Tax Reform” corporate front group, said net neutrality is like what China does, “putting policemen on every corner, on the street or on the Internet.” Watch it:

 

ThinkProgress has obtained a PowerPoint document which reveals how the telecom industry is orchestrating the latest campaign against Net Neutrality. Authored by representatives from the Atlas Network — a shell think tank used to coordinate corporate front group efforts worldwide — the document lays out the following strategy:

– Slides 7-8 calls for the campaign to target “libertarian minded internet users and video gamers” and “social conservative activists” with anti-government messages and a rebranding of net neutrality as “Net Brutality.”

– Slide 9 calls for a strategy of creating a Chinese blog to compare net neutrality to Chinese government censorship, outreach via social networking platforms like Twitter and Facebook.

– Slides 10-11 detail how representatives met at Grover Norquist’s infamous “Wednesday morning meeting” to orchestrate the new campaign. Norquist is known to use his Wednesday meetings to plot strategy and conservative coalition building towards lobbying goals.

The PowerPoint was created on April 14th, shortly before the campaign website officially launched. The “Net Brutality” [corporocon delinked] website relies heavily on Americans for Prosperity sources, as well as a website called NetCompetition.org — which is openly funded ][corporocon delinked] by the American Cable Association, At&T, Comcast, and the US Telecom Association.

During the Jack Abramoff investigation, Norquist was exposed for selling support from his front groups to corporations. In one damning e-mail, Norquist is promised $50,000 dollars in exchange for providing his Americans for Tax Reform support to one of Abramoff’s clients. Today, Norquist was not only parroting the PowerPoint talking points at the press conference, but he also brought in other key conservative movement leaders and Republican lawmakers to the event.

In addition to the front groups, the loudest voice against net neutrality is still Glenn Beck, who has smeared free Internet proponents as Marxists and Communists, and has adopted the attack that net neutrality constitutes a “government takeover.” However, it is important to realize that even Beck is being fed with opposition research dug up by operatives at Americans for Prosperity. This research document, compiled by Americans for Prosperity staffers, lays out point by point the attacks Beck has used in the past few weeks to disparage net neutrality supporters. If Beck picks up this new outreach to video game enthusiasts and the false comparison to Chinese censorship, then the impact of the “Net Brutality” PowerPoint will be even more apparent… [emphasis original]

 

Inserted from <Think Progress>

If you need a better understanding of why Net Neutrality is so important to keep, I explained it on May 6.  Be sure of this.  If the giant telecoms has an honest explanation for their position, they would not be planning a phony Chinese blog to deceive you.  This is a fight we must win.

Corporations are NOT people!  Money is NOT speech!

Share