Loophole!

 Posted by at 2:37 am  Politics
Dec 122009
 

The Nevada Leg Hound, Harry Reid, tried to pull a fast one, selling us out to make the CBO numbers look better.

loophole Ezra has a post today, talking about the important rule that healthcare reform is going to establish. "As the exchanges open up — if they open up, more to the point — all of this will work better and more smoothly. This is how the Netherlands’ health-care system looks, and few would accuse their insurers of being evil."

The problem with this argument, the problem many of us of had all along, is that the United States is not the Netherlands. We don’t have a private industry that is particularly committed to following the rules, nor do we have a government that is particularly adept at enforcing them. But it’s even worse than that–we have a Congress that’s already subverting the rules before they’ve even started.

WASHINGTON — A loophole in the Senate health care bill would let insurers place annual dollar limits on medical care for people struggling with costly illnesses such as cancer, prompting a rebuke from patient advocates.

The legislation that originally passed the Senate health committee last summer would have banned such limits, but a tweak to that provision weakened it in the bill now moving toward a Senate vote.

As currently written, the Senate Democratic health care bill would permit insurance companies to place annual limits on the dollar value of medical care, as long as those limits are not "unreasonable." The bill does not define what level of limits would be allowable, delegating that task to administration officials.

Adding to the puzzle, the new language was quietly tucked away in a clause in the bill still captioned "No lifetime or annual limits."

Maybe they were hoping nobody was going to read what was actually under the section title until the bill was actually passed and signed by Obama. Who, btw, as Jane points out expressly promised that lifetime limits on coverage would be banned in his healthcare speech on September 10. That’s a promise that the Senate can’t break.

Let’s just get this clear–annual limits are just as pernicious as lifetime limits, perhaps even more so. Here’s Stephen Finan, a policy expert with the cancer society’s advocacy affiliate.

"The primary purpose of insurance is to protect people against catastrophic loss," Finan said. "If you put a limit on benefits, by definition it’s going to affect people who are dealing with catastrophic loss." The cost of cancer treatment can exceed $100,000 a year.

…..

But Finan said the change in the Senate bill essentially invalidates the legislation’s ban on lifetime limits.

"If you can have annual limits, saying there’s no lifetime limits becomes meaningless," he said. A patient battling aggressive disease in its later stages could conceivably exhaust insurance benefits in the course of a year.

My brother-in-law’s treatment for a rare and aggressive lymphoma reached over $400,000 in nine months, and by the luck of the draw he had fantastic insurance that covered it all. But that’s not something that should be left to the luck of the draw for anyone, particularly after the system has supposedly been reformed.

This provision is a deal-breaker, and now that it’s been exposed will undoubtedly be removed in the manager’s amendment. But it’s a great example of the larger problem in our system… [emphasis original]

Inserted from <Daily Kos>

Could anyone have made a better case for publicly financed elections?  As long as Senators and Representatives are given an incentive to place the desires of those who finance their campaigns over those who elect them, we will have the best government money can buy… and does.

Share
Dec 122009
 

Some more good news!

A US District Court judge has granted a preliminary injunction against last September’s defunding of anti-poverty group ACORN by a vote of Congress.

NoWhining ACORN had filed a lawsuit claiming that Congress’s action violated the explicit Constitutional prohibition against bills of attainder — punishments handed out to an isolated individual or group by legislative proceedings rather than through the courts.

The judge agreed that "the plaintiffs have raised a fundamental issue of separation of powers. They have been singled out by Congress for punishment that directly and immediately affects their ability to continue to obtain federal funding, in the absence of any judicial, or administrative, process adjudicating guilt."

Representatives of ACORN and of the Center for Constitutional Rights, which brought the suit on their behalf, were jubilant following the ruling. CCR Vice President Jules Lobel was quoted in a CCR press release as saying, "This historic decision by the Court affirms the fundamental constitutional principle that the Congress cannot be judge, jury, and executioner."

ACORN Executive Director Bertha Lewis proclaimed that "the court’s decision is a victory not only for the many dedicated citizens who work with ACORN to improve their communities and promote responsible lending and homeownership, but for the Constitution and the rights of all Americans."

Immediately following the release last September of amateur videos showing ACORN employees seemingly offering advice on how to set up an illegal prostitution ring, there was a rush to judgment on the part of both Congress and the media. There have been suggestions all along, however, that ACORN was guilty of nothing more than sloppy record-keeping and lax oversight, and leftwing website have recently begun to cast doubt on whether the heavily-edited videos themselves can stand up to scrutiny.

A Justice Department opinion issued a few weeks ago, suggesting that the Congressional vote could not legally be used to cut off federal payments to ACORN for services that had already been performed, was condemned by Rep. Darrell Issa (R-CA) as "shameful." This new injunction is likely to call forth more of the same sort of Republican outrage…

Inserted from <Raw Story>

The Republicans have no right to whine over this.  Two months ago I said this law would not pass Constitutional muster, because it is a bill of attainder.

Share
Dec 112009
 

I think we can all agree that the one thing TARP accomplished is to socialize the losses brought on by corporate irresponsibility and greed, freeing the banksters to continue their fat bonus checks and conspicuous consumption.  Here are two solutions to dealing with TARP:  Tim Geithner’s and mine.

Bankster A day ahead of testimony in which he’s sure to be grilled about the controversial taxpayer-funded bank bailout program, Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner announced Wednesday that he wants to extend it into late 2010."History suggests that exiting prematurely from policies designed to contain a financial crisis can significantly prolong an economic downturn," Geithner wrote in a letter Wednesday to House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif.

The Troubled Asset Relief Program, widely known as TARP, will continue until October 3, 2010, Geithner said, arguing for prudence in keeping an unpopular program afloat until almost the end of next year.

"We must not waver in our resolve to ensure the stability of the financial system and to support the nascent recovery that the administration and Congress have worked so hard to achieve," he said…

Inserted from <Common Dreams>

Why am I not surprised to see Geithner supporting the extension of the taxpayer funded gravy train for Wall Street?

us_tax_rates My solution may be a bit simplistic, but it represents a complete about face from Geithner’s socialism for the rich policies.  First, I call on Obama once again to fire Geithner and Bernanke, to appoint Elizabeth Warren at Treasury and to appoint whomever she recommends at the Fed.  Second, as the big banks pay back the TARP funds, let’s invest all that money in Main Street through job creation spending on infrastructure and establishing a green manufacturing base.  Third, we must muzzle the bankster’s greed through exhaustive oversight and iron-clad regulation.  Fourth, too big to fail is too big to exist.  Break up the banksters.  Fifth, and perhaps most important, we must correct the travesty that ultimately led to the crisis.  Years of GOP No Millionaire Left Behind policies, have skewed the wealth in our nation so extensively that the bottom 40% of Americans own only 0.2% of the wealth, while the top 10% own 58.9%.  The bankster’s crooks were able to sucker people into ninja loans only because they could not maintain their standard of living without using the equity in their homes.  Why?  Costs increased, but real wages fell, as the nation’s wealth flowed into the pockets of the super-rich.  It’s time for these beneficiaries to give back some of the largesse they have received at American taxpayers’ expense.  It’s time to finance health care reform, clean energy reform, and education reform using a healthy surtax on millionaires.  The tired old argument against this is that it will hurt the economy by limiting the rich people’s ability to create jobs with their investments.  That is a lie.  They are investing for paper profits that produce little if anything of value.  paper profits produce no jobs.  Furthermore, history tells a different story.  I found the above statistics this morning at Crooks and Liars.  The top marginal tax rate (what the super-rich pay, before loopholes) in the US stayed above 75% from 1941 – 1981.  Throughout most of that time, business boomed and investment capital was plentiful.

What do you think?

Share
Dec 112009
 

I am constantly amazed how wing-nuts always claim to know what is important to the American people.

Rove-O'Lielly The disgraced man once known as Bush’s Brain actually has the nerve to say that the reason President Obama’s poll numbers are slipping is because he’s wasting time trying to fix our broken f*&king health care system and that’s not one of the real "bread and butter" issues that Americans care about.

This from the man who led George W. Bush from an 80% approval rating to one of the lowest approval ratings in the history of America. And George Bush is considered one of the worst President in American history… Oh, yeah, and Karl couldn’t help but drool all over himself when he said that Obama is focusing on climate change and never stops talking about his Nobel Peace Prize. When have you ever heard the president mention his prize outside of when he won it, and now that he’s picking it up? What a liar.

Rove: ..and he’s spent this year talking about health care and talking about greenhouse gas emissions and the environment and his Nobel Peace Prize and not talking about the thing that Americans are concerned about, which is jobs and the economy…

BillO: Bread and butter issues.

You may not agree with some of the measures President Obama has taken in dealing with the economy or health care for that matter, but he’s certainly addressed it… [emphasis added]

 

Inserted from <Crooks and Liars>

 

Only true GOP Sweethearts could so thoroughly distort the truth.  And what are the bread and butter issues that consume the GOP?  Obama’s birth certificate, the war on Christmas, and cutting taxes for the rich.

Share
Dec 112009
 

I found several interesting items on health care today.  First is an article by Michael Bard.

Senate …Many are lamenting the demise of the public option, but I thought of three things about the reported deal that actually make me happy:

1) Finally, the Democrats figured out that the power to make a deal lies with them, not with the Republicans. Back in September, I begged the Democrats to forget about the Republicans (who were only pretending to engage as a way of stalling progress), caucus, and come to a compromise that all 58 Democrats and the two independents could support. I have criticized the Democrats for failing to properly use the power of their majority in Congress and the mandate from an overwhelming victory last November, so it’s only right I give them their props for finally taking charge.

My favorite element of this story, from a political gamesmanship point of view, is the statement from Republican Sen. John Thune of South Dakota that all 40 Republicans would oppose the Democratic compromise, even if the public option is off the table. It was such an entertaining moment, since Thune’s statement meant absolutely nothing. How nice for you, Sen. Thune, that you and your 39 colleagues will stand together to support health insurance companies and oppose health care reform for Americans. But your opposition will have zero effect if the 58 Democrats and two independents agree to a deal. Thune and his 39 fellow Republicans will be powerless to stop health care reform from happening if the other 60 senators stand together.

Essentially, Thune’s statement is like the temper tantrum of an eight-year-old who isn’t getting what he wants: it’s annoying but doesn’t change anything.

It is quite enjoyable to read about a health care deal that doesn’t involve what Olympia Snowe, Susan Collins or any other Republican whose agenda is to torpedo real reform wants. I don’t care what they think. And if the 60 other senators really have made a deal, I don’t have to.

2) I have come to the conclusion that no public option is better than a weak one. From the beginning, I have supported Rep. Anthony Weiner’s proposal to extend Medicare to all Americans. The public option was meant to be a compromise between the left’s desire for a single-payer system and the right’s claim to oppose governmental intervention in health care. Somehow, the public option became the left’s position in the debate, essentially taking the compromise position to begin with, even though the Democrats controlled both houses of Congress and the White House. Once it became clear that centrist Democrats (who enjoy riding on the financial coattails of health insurance and pharmaceutical companies) opposed the public option, it became clear that if such an option did end up in the legislation, it would be so watered down by triggers or other gimmicks that it no longer would have effectively done the job it was there to do: provide competition for private insurers and keep costs down.

If a weak public option became law, and it didn’t work to bring down costs and expand coverage options (since it would have been set up to fail in the compromise), the perception would be that the idea itself failed (even though that wouldn’t be the case). Given a choice between a weak public option destined to fail, and no public option with the reputation of the policy remaining intact, I’ll take the latter every time. It leaves us with the opportunity to fight another day when those suffering under a system with lack of choice and high rates become more open to a governmental solution to address the crippling problem.

As an example, I offer the stimulus legislation. Democratic leadership allowed the Republicans and centrist Democrats to decrease the amount of the bill and to load it up with useless tax cuts. The result? Complaints that the stimulus bill didn’t do enough to create jobs. Seems ridiculous, right? Make a proposal to address something, have your opponents water it down so it can no longer remedy the problem (or not work as well), and then blame the program for not providing a solution. I don’t want to see the same absurd dance play out again with the public option.

3) A win is important both politically and in practice for those struggling without health insurance. The side of me that loves the game of politics thinks that if after a year of battling and enduring lies and other desperate measures thrown out from the right (death panels, funding abortion on demand, keeping Americans from seeing their own doctors, socialism, etc., I rounded up some of the crazy statements by Republicans in Congress here) the Democrats can get a health care reform bill through to President Obama’s desk, something no other Congress has done in the last half century of trying, it will be a huge blow to the Republicans and conservatives who have fought this battle. Similarly, failing to pass health care reform legislation would be a deadly blow to the Democrats. So from the political point of view, getting something like the reported compromise through Congress would be huge for the Democrats.

More importantly, though, there are a lot of people suffering in the United States right now because they can’t afford health coverage. According to the nonpartisan National Coalition on Health Care, 54 million Americans under the age of 65 lacked health insurance in the first half of 2007, with 7 million more estimated to lose their insurance by next year. The Republicans may want to protect their corporate benefactors, but something has to be done for the tens of millions of our fellow citizens in need. The current health care legislation may give too much to the health insurance and drug companies that have helped create the current mess in which we find ourselves, and it may not provide the kind of coverage and cost control many of us would like to see. But it will make life better for millions of Americans who are suffering right now with a lack of health care in a difficult economy. As much as I think politics is important, it is even more important to provide the citizens of our country with affordable health care, and the reported compromise is better than nothing for those in need. It may even represent a start, the first step in a process of true health care reform… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <Huffington Post>

While Bard raises some excellent points, I’m still withholding judgment until I know exactly what’s in there. 

However, there is a flaw in the idea of the insurance exchange so drastic that it requires immediate action.

Lieberman_puppet_SM Here’s another reason to nix the whole exchange within the exchange that the OPM-regulated national non-profit provider model offers. Guess who would be in charge of oversight of it (sub. req.) in the Senate?

The plan emerging from negotiations among moderate and liberal Democrats would put a key part of the planned health insurance exchanges under the supervision of the Office of Personnel Management (OPM). And jurisdiction for oversight of OPM falls to the centrist-dominated Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee, which Lieberman chairs.

Lieberman barely retained his chairmanship after campaigning for Republican Sen. John McCain of Arizona in last year’s presidential race, and there would likely be talk among Democrats of dumping him from the position in the next Congress — or even earlier — if his opposition sinks health care legislation. Lieberman, whose state is home to major insurers, has taken a my-way-or-the-highway position in opposing any form of government-run insurance plan.

Lieberman said he was aware that the scope of his committee’s oversight would be expanded, but he said that will not be a factor in his view of the latest proposal… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <Daily Kos>

That will not do.  Before LIEberman gets oversight of Health care reform, he needs to be kicked out of the caucus.

On a positive note, Sen. Byron Dorgan (D-ND) has introduced a bill that I filly support.

healthcare-reform After a long summer of committee debates and discussions with constituents, health care reform is finally out in the open on the Senate floor — but it doesn’t include much of anything to lower drug prices. And the big drug companies are pulling out all the stops to keep it that way.

I’ve offered a bipartisan amendment that would give the American people the freedom to purchase prescription drugs from other countries at a fraction of the price they are required to pay here. As you know, the American people are charged the highest prices in the world for brand-name prescription drugs. Those same drugs are sold elsewhere at a much lower price. I want the American people to have the ability to force the pharmaceutical companies to offer fair prices here in the United States.

My legislation will get that done.

This is a crucial reform that’s urgently needed to combat one of the fastest-rising costs associated with health care — the skyrocketing price of prescription drugs. The cost of prescription drugs increased by just over 9 percent this year alone!

I hope you will contact your senators today to ensure that they’ve joined me in supporting the prescription drug importation bill… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <Huffington Post>

That’s an idea that’s long past due, and while we’re on the subject of Dorgan, Rachel Maddow had a little fun with his example of how ridiculous medical advertising has become.

 

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

Perhaps the Senate should adopt a new rule that, whenever the Repuglicans filibuster, the Senate rest rooms are closed until cloture is reached.

Share

Dean Supports Compromise

 Posted by at 2:00 am  Politics
Dec 102009
 

Howard Dean has thrown his support behind the deal worked out on health care legislation.  At this point, I no longer feel confident enough to call it reform.

howard-dean-dnc Count Howard Dean in among those who support the idea of replacing the public option with Medicare buy-in for Americans between the ages of 55 and 64 along with a set of other measures. His support, however, is contingent on whether the buy-in will be available to people who receive subsidies for health care coverage.

Speaking with Keith Olbermann on Countdown, Dean called the Medicare buy-in "a very good idea," noting that he had proposed the same thing in his 2004 presidential campaign. Dean said the proposal would add more health care insurance choices, albeit only for those between 55 and 64. He also said that one of its advantages relative to the public option was that it wouldn’t require the creation of a new bureaucracy,  because it would be built on top of an existing program.

Dean also noted that because Medicare currently exists, people could start getting enrolled in 2010, years ahead of when the public option would have kicked in.

In a separate interview with Greg Sargent, Dean raised a warning flag, however. Dean said that if those opting for Medicare buy-in were not eligible for subsidies, it would render the option unavailable to most people creating a potential "deal-breaker." According to TPM, people choosing Medicare would be eligible for subsidies, but not until 2014 when subsidies for everybody else participating in the exchange becomes available…

Inserted from <Daily Kos>

It may well be that this so-called compromise is an improvement on a public option that was so gutted that it was not public and not an option for more than about three million people.  I understand that Representatives Anthony Weiner and Alan Grayson, both staunch public option advocates, also support it.  Still, the devil is in the details, which Harry Reid refuses to release until it is scored by the CBO.  Therefore, I am still withholding my judgment on the matter until I know much more.

Share
Dec 102009
 

If the Supreme Court throws this law out, justice may be undone, freeing several despicable characters sooner.

abramoff An anti-corruption law that has been central to the convictions of numerous public officials and corporate executives in recent years could be at risk of being struck down or narrowed after it was met with extreme skepticism by the U.S. Supreme Court yesterday.

The honest services law, enacted in 1988, makes it a crime "to deprive another of the intangible right of honest services." Prosecutors frequently use it against politicians or corporate executives believed to have defrauded their constituents or employers. Jack Abramoff, former congressman William Jefferson, former Enron CEO Jeff Skilling, and newspaper magnate Conrad Black all have been convicted, at least in part, of honest services fraud in the last few years.

The Supreme Court yesterday heard arguments in two separate cases related to the law — one involving Black, who was convicted of defrauding his company, and the other involving Bruce Weyhrauch, the Alaska GOP legislator convicted for failing to disclose that he had solicited business from an oil-services company with business before the legislature. According to the New York Times, justices from both the court’s liberal and conservative wings showed outright hostility to the law, suggesting that they saw it as overly vague.

Reports the Times:

Justice Steven G. Breyer estimated that there are 150 million workers in the United States and that perhaps 140 million of them could be prosecuted under the government’s interpretation of the law.

Complimenting the boss’s hat "so the boss will leave the room so that the worker can continue to read The Racing Form," Justice Breyer said, could amount to a federal crime.

If the law goes down, pretty much anyone else convicted of honest services fraud could benefit. "There will be a rush to the courthouse," Stan Brand, a veteran Washington ethics lawyer, told TPMmuckraker. Even those like Abramoff and Jefferson who were convicted on multiple counts, honest-services fraud among them, could get their sentences shortened. "Where you’ve got multiple counts, they’re not gonna get a pass, but they could get a reduction," Brand said…

Inserted from <TPM>

Frankly, the longer the GOP’s favorite financier, Jack Abramoff, serves, the better.  Due to the embarrassment he caused my party, I have to desire to see Dollar Bill get a break either.  However, if the law is truly unclear the potential for Republican ideologue activist judges to misapply it, and the Court should send it back to Congress for repair.  If some people who shouldn’t get a pass in the process, so be it.

Share