Bernanke’s Failure

 Posted by at 1:57 am  Politics
Dec 222009
 

Here’s an excellent analysis I found this morning.

BernankeBendOver Foreclosures already pocked Chicago’s poorer neighborhoods but the downtown still was booming as the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago convened its annual conference in May 2007.The keynote speaker, Federal Reserve Chairman Ben S. Bernanke, assured the bankers and businessmen gathered at the Westin Hotel on Michigan Avenue that their prosperity was not threatened by the plight of borrowers struggling to repay high-cost subprime loans.

Bernanke, who was in charge of regulating the nation’s largest banks, told the audience that these firms were not at risk. He said most were not even involved in subprime lending. And the broader economy, he concluded, would be fine.

"Importantly, we see no serious broad spillover to banks or thrift institutions from the problems in the subprime market," Bernanke said. "The troubled lenders, for the most part, have not been institutions with federally insured deposits."

He was wrong. Five of the 10 largest subprime lenders during the previous year were banks regulated by the Fed. Even as Bernanke spoke, the spillover from subprime lending was driving the banking industry into a historic crisis that some firms would not survive. And the upheaval would shove the economy into recession.

Just as the Fed had failed to protect borrowers from the consequences of subprime lending, so too had it failed to protect banks.

The central bank’s performance has sparked a great debate about its future as a regulator, pitting those who want to expand its role against those who want to strip its powers. It also has come under pressure from politicians seeking greater oversight of its primary job, adjusting interest rates to moderate economic growth. The battles have complicated Bernanke’s bid for a second term as chairman. The Senate Banking Committee voted to approve Bernanke 16 to 7 on Thursday, setting the stage for a January battle on the Senate floor.

The Fed’s failure to foresee the crisis or to require adequate safeguards happened in part because it did not understand the risks that banks were taking, according to documents and interviews with more than three dozen current and former government officials, bank executives and regulatory experts.

Regulatory agencies exist to lean against the wind. But rather than looking for warning signs, the Fed had joined — and at times defined — the mainstream consensus among policymakers that financial innovations had made banking safer. Bernanke said the economy had entered an era of smaller and less frequent downturns, which he and others called "the great moderation."

The consequences of this miscalculation can be seen in the stories of three large banks the government ultimately rescued from collapse… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <Washington Post>

This is less than the first page from a five page article that goes into much more detail.  I encourage you to click through and read it all.

I disagree with the folks who want to do away with the Fed.  I think we need a central bank to enact monetary policy.  However, I think that the Fed’s role should be restricted to monetary policy only, with all fiscal regulation in the hands of another agency.  In addition, the Fed as a hybrid organization of shared power that is mostly in the hands of banksters is obsolete.  The Fed needs to be moved fully under government control, because banksters have proven they are too disingenuous to oversee their own privies, let alone our nation’s monetary policy.  There are none to whom this applies more than Ben Bernanke.  He should be removed from the Fed, just as Geithner should be removed from Treasury and Summers from his post as Chief Economic Advisor.

Share

LIEberman Surprised Harkin

 Posted by at 1:56 am  Politics
Dec 222009
 

Progressives have vented considerable ire, based on this claim.

asshole_Lieberman Sen. Tom Harkin (D-IA) said on MSNBC he was surprised that Sen. Joe Lieberman told reporters the White House didn’t pressure him to support a public option.

Harkin, a progressive who wanted to see a public option in the health care bill, said he’d "assumed" that President Obama would have been pushing Lieberman (I-CT) at all costs since that’s what Senate Democrats ultimately compromised on to secure Lieberman’s vote.

"I’m really surprised at that. I would have thought that President Obama, I know he met a number of times with Sen. Lieberman, and Sen. Nelson and others," Harkin said. "I assumed that they were pushing hard for the public option. … The senator said ‘No’ under any circumstance and that’s why we had to do the compromise."

Lieberman told Huffington Post his negotiations on the public option were with Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid.

From their story:

"Well, no. I think I got pressure from the president to be for health care reform," Lieberman said when asked by HuffPost about any pressure from the administration to support either the public option or the Medicare buy-in. "I’d have to think about this, but I didn’t really have direct input from the White House on this."…

Inserted from <TPM>

Now, I’m not saying that it didn’t come down just the way Traitor Joe said it did.  Asking him to support the public option would be no more likely to achieve results than presenting the request directly to Aetna’s CEO.  However, Traitor Joe is leaving himself and out by saying he have to think about it.  Furthermore, my momma had a special word for anyone who bases anything on what a serial lair says: fool.

Share
Dec 212009
 

Here’s how desperate the GOP has gotten in their attempts to defeat the health care bill in the Senate.

Coburn-C Street 

Senator Tom Coburn (R-OK) is hoping, even praying, that one of his Democratic colleagues somehow cannot manage to cast a vote on health care in the wee hours of Monday morning.

As the chamber nears the first of several procedural ballots to end debate on the bill ahead of final passage, Coburn said, "What the American people ought to pray is that somebody can’t make the vote tonight. That’s what they ought to pray."

His suggestion, seemingly a veiled remark aimed at ailing 92-year-old Senator Robert Byrd (D-VA), struck a raw nerve with Senator Dick Durbin (D-IL). "I don’t think it’s appropriate to be invoking prayer to wish misfortune on a colleague…

Inserted from <Raw Story>

Only a true GOP Sweetheart would call on the Supply-side Jesus (The GOP invention, not the real one) to bring harm to a colleague to prevent a fair vote.

Share
Dec 212009
 

Jeffrey Feldman wrote a fascinating article on just how duplicitous Rahm Emanuel had been to get health care passed.  Put your breakables under lock and key, away from your computer, before reading this.

Rahm-Emanuel As frustrated as the base of the Democratic Party may be in this late stage of the health care reform battle, few have reflected on the force behind every legislative battle this year: Rahm Emanuel.

In a blunt remark to the Wall Street Journal, the White House Chief of Staff tipped his hand on how he planned to get 60 votes in the Senate: bring left-wing Democrats on board early to generate enthusiasm, then turn on them in the end game to woo conservatives.

In other words: Get ’em, then gut ’em.

Responding as to whether or not the White House was concerned about "noise" from liberals, (i.e., threats that liberals will "kill" rather than vote for a health care bill that includes a mandate, but no public option), Emanuel made two very telling statements.

First, Emanuel gestured to the vote tally by saying,"There are no liberals left to get." In other words: liberal Democrats committed to supporting the White House early in the game, such that Emanuel has long since given up in interested in the concerns of those who support left-wing Democrats.

Second, and in jarring contrast to his first statement in the Wall Street Journal interview, Emanuel then blamed liberal Democrats for every failure to pass a health care bill in the past, "Every time they’ve gotten close to the deal, they’ve passed up the opportunity and chosen to walk away from a particular [sic] where they’ve lost the forest for the trees." By referring to the liberal Democrats as "they," Emanuel makes it clear that to bring on conservative Democrats in the Senate, he is willing to split the party into two sides: those who are working to pass a health care bill, and those with a long record of blocking a bill–us and them.

Indeed, if we recall the way the health care bill was unfolded, the White House began by wrapping their early efforts in the most liberal of liberal Democratic packages: the image of Sen. Edward Kennedy. This early phase of the debate featured liberal Democrats in the Senate as a tactic for bringing in the base and generating enthusiasm. Certainly, health care reform was also Kennedy’s legacy, but in terms of political strategy Kennedy was also Emanuel’s early game outreach to the liberal base.

And once he "got" liberals, Emanuel turned his attention to conservatives.

Short of Emanuel calling liberal Democrats "socialists," it is difficult to imagine a more direct attack on early supporters of his own whip effort than his inflammatory statements in the Wall Street journal. Emanuel makes it clear that, at this late stage of the game, liberal Democrats will be castigated as the killers of health care reform throughout American history, if they dare to complain about discrepancies with earlier versions of the bill.

"Get ’em early, gut ’em later" is a strategy that leads to 60 votes and a base that feels like they have been sold down the river. And, yet, it leads to 60 votes. Thus, every legislative item on the Obama White House reform agenda has passed, while the base has slowly simmered to the boiling point.

Curiously, liberal and progressive members of the Democratic Party have felt the downside of Emanuel’s strategy at a visceral level, but have not yet found an effective way to make it work to their advantage.

Most liberals and progressive in the Democratic base insist that Emanuel’s "get ’em early, gut ’em later" strategy will lead only to Pyrrhic policy victories for the White House: legislation so compromised that party activists refuse to turn out the vote in 2010 and 2012.

And yet, if considered from a more tactical perspective, Emanuel’s Wall Street Journal interview suggests that the base of the party suffers from a fundamental weakness when it comes to legislative negotiations: liberal idealism leads the base to sign on so early to White House reform efforts, that it forfeits any subsequent role in the critical end game.

Greater end game influence for liberals and progressives, in other words, is about strategy, not ideals–tactics, not rhetoric.

Given the likelihood that elected Democrats would rather stiff arm activists in their own base than be publicly accused by their own President of blocking health care reform–meaning that the current health care bill will likely be signed into law rather than killed–what can the base of the Democratic Party do to guarantee they have more end game influence in the next legislative battle?

As painful as it may seem, the best tactics just might come from the likes of Ben Nelson and Joe Lieberman.

Learn from Lieberman? Just reading that suggestion is enough to make most liberals want to gauge out their own eyes in horror. And who can blame them. Lieberman has become the symbol of political egotism who has stood up and blocked reform.

And yet, both Nelson and Lieberman have managed to make themselves key players in the health care end game by following a few basic tactics. They stay relatively quiet early, keep an ace in the hole (such as, anti-government spending or an anti-abortion amendment), avoid inflammatory rhetoric in favor of seeing ten steps ahead in the whip count, and finally: they have been willing to step out late in the game to hold a bill hostage no matter how loudly their constituents and the media attacked them.

All of these techniques require party activists to engage in some efforts that have not, heretofore, been their strong suits: back room planning, anticipating the details of legislative fights, cultivating reciprocal relationships on Capital Hill, a well-run ground game, keeping one’s card’s close, cultivating the media, and–most importantly: good end game timing.

Such a complicated effort cannot happen overnight. By Christmas next year, however, liberals and progressives in the Democratic Party would have had plenty of time to take the first steps towards greater influence in reform legislation… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <Huffington Post>

I think part of the problem here is that, unlike some of the people Obama has foolishly chosen to advise him, and also unlike the entire leadership of the GOP, progressives tend to be honest and above board and expect the same in return.  It is now clear that will not happen.  I disagree with Feldman’s suggestion that we become more like LIEberman and ‘Coat-hanger’ Nelson, but we still need to admit that we’ve been suckered, lick our wounds, and learn from the experience.  In future, we need to draw our line in the sand early in the process and refuse to budge until near the end.  While I acknowledge that compromise is a necessary part of governance, we must avoid jumping on the band wagon until it becomes clear that we will get most of what we want in exchange for our support.

Many of you become upset at the mere mention of anything critical of President Obama.  Personally, I think that Obama meant what he said during his campaign.  However, we must all acknowledge that he has surrounded himself with advisors that share neither his ideals nor his integrity: Geithner, Axelrod, Summers, and worst of all, Emanuel.  We have until 2012 to convince Obama that, if he expects progressives to get out the vote for him and give him a second term, he needs to, at the very least, reign in his neoliberal advisors and demand that they give us our rightful place.  A better move would be to replace them with the progressive advisors that managed his campaign.  Obama would not be President without our efforts on his behalf.  He needs to be reminded of that.

Share
Dec 212009
 

It’s a win for Obama, but less so for America.

60 votes The Senate took a giant step toward passing its sweeping healthcare bill early today, uniting fractious Democrats after months of debate over President Obama’s promise to reduce the ranks of the uninsured.

Breaking the Republican filibuster required the votes of all 60 members of the Democratic caucus. The cloture motion, which passed 60 to 40, capped months of work by Obama and Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.), who personally negotiated compromises on big issues such as abortion and taxes, as well as parochial deals for key states and industries.

But with final Senate approval of the bill expected this week, Democrats and the White House were moving to shift the focus from their dozens of concessions — such as jettisoning a government alternative to private health insurance — toward the momentous changes they said it would bring: providing insurance access to 31 million more Americans, cracking down on insurance practices, and beginning to curb healthcare cost inflation.

"I wish this bill were different," Assistant Majority Leader Richard J. Durbin (D-Ill.) said on the Senate floor Sunday, reflecting liberals’ unhappiness over some compromises with conservatives in the party…

Inserted from <LA Times>

Like Durbin, I also wish the bill were different.

Share
Dec 202009
 

Leg Hound Harry finally released his Amendment, and Bitch McConnell insisted that it be read on the Senate floor in it’s entirety.  That took all day, giving me time to do a little research.  Here’s a summary of the changes:

…

  • Insurance greed 2 Stronger medical loss ratios. Health insurers will be required to spend more of their premium revenues on clinical services and quality activities, with less going to administrative costs and profits – or else pay rebates to policyholders. These stricter limits will continue even after the Exchanges begin in 2011, and apply to all plans, including grandfathered plans. (Ed note: Reportedly, these require group insurance plans to pay 85% of premiums to health care, and individual plans to pay 80%. These would go into effect in 2011. In 2012, the ratios would be based on the average medical loss ratio in the Exchange.)
  • Accountability for excessive rate increases. A health insurer’s participation in the Exchanges will depend on its performance. Insurers that jack up their premiums before the Exchanges begin will be excluded – a powerful incentive to keep premiums affordable.
  • Immediate ban on pre-existing condition exclusions for children. Health insurers will be immediately prohibited from excluding coverage of pre-existing conditions for children.
  • Patient protections. Health insurers will have to abide by a set of patient protections that, for example, protect choice of doctors and ensure access to emergency care.
  • Ensuring access to needed care. The use of annual limits on benefits will be tightly restricted to ensure access to needed care immediately, and will be prohibited completely beginning in 2014.
  • Guaranteed opportunity to appeal coverage denials. All health insurers will be required to implement an internal appeals process for coverage denials, and states will ensure the availability of an external appeals process that is independent and holds insurance companies accountable.
  • Multi-state option. Health insurance carriers will offer plans under the supervision of the Office of Personnel Management, the same entity that oversees health plans for Members of Congress. At least one plan must be non-profit, and the plans will be available nationwide. This will promote competition and choice. (Ed note: At least two plans will have to be offered, one of which must be non-profit. OPM can negotiate medical loss ratio, profits, premiums and other terms.)
  • Free choice vouchers. Workers who qualify for an affordability exemption to the individual responsibility policy but do not qualify for tax credits can take their employer contribution and join an exchange plan.
  • Children’s health. Support will be extended for the Children’s Health Insurance Program and the adoption tax credit. Foster care children aging out of Medicaid will be able to retain its comprehensive coverage.
  • Rural and underserved communities. Access will be expanded through funding for rural health care providers and training programs for physician and other types of health care providers.
  • Revised abortion language, including state opt-out of abortion coverage…

Inserted from <Health Care For America Now>

Some of the provisions are not too bad.  Mandated medical loss ratios are a good thing, but the level is too low.  Companies should be required to pay out 90%-95%.  I like the idea that companies that jack up their rates will be excluded from the exchange, but I want to know how much is too much and who makes that decision.  I favor the immediate ban on pre-existing conditions, but for everyone, not just for children.  Until I know what patient protections are guaranteed, I can’t comment on that provision.  Annual limits should be prohibited immediately.  Nationwide plans have more bargaining power than state plans.  I also like the free choice vouchers.  I favor extending CHIP support.  Funding rural health care is a bribe.  I’ll cover that later.

The most controversial aspect of the Reid Amendment is the abortion sell-out.

…Under the new abortion provisions, states can opt out of allowing plans to cover abortion in the insurance exchanges the bill would set up. The exchanges are designed to serve individuals who lack coverage through their jobs, with most receiving federal subsidies to buy insurance. Enrollees in plans that cover abortion procedures would pay with separate checks — one for abortion, one for any other health-care services… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <Washington Post>

I find this provision inacceptable.  It amounts to a coat hanger mandate in Red States, and a violation of privacy everywhere, that is so extreme that I doubt it will pass  muster when it receives judicial scrutiny.  It’s shameful!

And ironically, it’s not strong enough for that C-Street DINO, Stupak.

An aide to Rep. Bart Stupak (D. Mich.) coordinated opposition to a Senate compromise on the place of abortion in health care legislation this morning with the Republican Senate leadership, the Conference Catholic Bishops, and other anti-abortion groups, according to a chain of frantic emails obtained this morning by POLITICO.

The emails show that Stupak – who has so far remained silent on language accepted by Senator Ben Nelson (D. Neb.) and faces intense pressure from the White House to accept it – is already working behind the scenes to oppose the compromise.

They also demonstrate a previously unseen degree of coordination between Stupak and the office of Republican leader Mitch McConnell… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <Common Dreams>

That’s right.  The rat is working with Bitch McConnell.

Needless to say, there is opposition from pro-choice Reps.

…But Reps. Diana DeGette (D-CO) and Louise Slaughter (D-NY)–co-chairs of the Congressional Pro-Choice Caucuse–say they’re not sold. They say the new compromise is possibly unconstitutional, and that they and other pro-choice House members could still reject it.

As the Co-Chairs of the Congressional Pro-Choice Caucus, we have serious reservations about the abortion provision included in the U.S. Senate’s health care bill. This provision is not only offensive to people who believe in choice, but it is also possibly unconstitutional. As we have maintained throughout this process, health care reform should not be misused to take away access to health care. The more than 190-member Caucus will review this language carefully as we move forward on health care reform.

The Nelson compromise may ultimately allow health care reform to pass in the Senate–but with strong opposition from both pro-life and pro-choice members and constituent groups, the language still an open question in the House. Onward to conference!

Inserted from <TPM>

We can only hope that the Conference committee will return the bill to the Capps standard.

Several states are getting special deals under this amendment.

…Ben Nelson’s “Cornhusker Kickback,” as the GOP is calling it, got all the attention Saturday, but other senators lined up for deals as Majority Leader Harry Reid corralled the last few votes for a health reform package.

Nelson’s might be the most blatant – a deal carved out for a single state, a permanent exemption from the state share of Medicaid expansion for Nebraska, meaning federal taxpayers have to kick in an additional $45 million in the first decade.

But another Democratic holdout, Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.), took credit for $10 billion in new funding for community health centers, while denying it was a “sweetheart deal.” He was clearly more enthusiastic about a bill he said he couldn’t support just three days ago.

Nelson and Sen. Carl Levin (D-Mich.) carved out an exemption for non-profit insurers in their states from a hefty excise tax. Similar insurers in the other 48 states will pay the tax.

Vermont and Massachusetts were given additional Medicaid funding, another plus for Sanders and Sen. Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.) Three states – Pennsylvania, New York and Florida – all won protections for their Medicare Advantage beneficiaries at a time when the program is facing cuts nationwide.

All of this came on top of a $300 million increase for Medicaid in Louisiana, designed to win the vote of Democratic Sen. Mary Landrieu…

Inserted from <Politico>

With one exception, all of this is grossly unfair.  Bernie Sanders deal for community health centers will benefit such programs nationwide, so it’s quite different from these other provisions that are nothing but bribes.

Here’s an excerpt from Joe Biden’s Op-Ed.

IF I were still a United States senator, I would not only vote yes on the current health care reform bill, I would do so with the sure knowledge that I was casting one of the most historic votes of my 36 years in the Senate. I would vote yes knowing that the bill represents the culmination of a struggle begun by Theodore Roosevelt nearly a century ago to make health care reform a reality. And while it does not contain every measure President Obama and I wanted, I would vote yes for this bill certain that it includes the fundamental, essential change that opponents of reform have resisted for generations.

We have been here before. In the past, as the moment of decision drew nearer, criticism from both the left and the right grew louder. Compromises were derided. The perfect became the enemy of the good.

Most recently, in 1993, Democrats had a chance to forge a compromise with Senator John Chafee, Republican of Rhode Island, on a health care reform bill. Congress’s failure to pass health care reform that year led to 16 years of inaction — and 16 years of exploding health care costs and rising numbers of uninsured Americans.

We can’t let that happen again. While it is not perfect, the bill pending in the Senate today is not just good enough — it is very good. Insurance companies will no longer be able to deny coverage to those with pre-existing conditions or drop coverage when people get sick. Charging exorbitant premiums based on sex, age or health status will be outlawed. Annual and lifetime caps on benefits will be history. Those who already have insurance will be able to keep it, and will gain peace of mind knowing they won’t be priced out of the market by skyrocketing premiums. And more than 30 million uninsured Americans will gain access to affordable health care coverage.

That is not all. President Obama and I know we have to put our fiscal house in order. This is why those who claim they oppose reform because they fear for our country’s fiscal stability should finally acknowledge what the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office makes crystal clear: not only is the Senate bill paid for, it is this country’s single largest deficit-reduction measure in a dozen years…

Inserted from <NY Times>

If you want my honest opinion, this bill stinks compared to what it could have been, had it been properly shepherded and had there protecting the giant corporations not been a priority.  Nevertheless it is not completely devoid of good qualities.

Whether we like it or not, barring some last minute grandstanding by Traitor Joe, this bill is going to pass the Senate.  Because the administration is so desperate to pass a bill and proclaim victory, they will exert intense pressure on the House to keep changes in conference to a minimum.  Nancy Pelosi will, after exacting some unknown future consideration from the White House, will play ball.  She will succeed in getting it through conference with few changes if any.  What we see now is essentially what we’re going to get.  I’m not saying we shouldn’t keep fighting to make it better.  We should.  But our voices will appear to be falling on deaf ears.  The party has too much political capital invested into passing a bill now.

We have two choices after we finish bitching and ranting about how lousy this is.  I’m sure I will do my share.  We say we don’t matter, abandon the Democrats, talk third parties and become completely ineffective politically, or we can work to build public support for passing more legislation next year to fix what’s wrong with this bill.  I’ll be making the latter choice, and I strongly hope you will too.

Share
Dec 192009
 

Tom122007 The manager’s amendment aka the Reid Amendment that denoted the final Senate version has been released.  The Repuglicans insisted that it be read in it’s entirety to further delay the process.  The Senate Clerk began doing so at 7:35 AM EST (4:35 AM PST) and is expected to finish around 3:00 PM EST (Noon PST), about two hours from now.

I looked at it, but integrating it back into the original would take me days by myself.  So I’ll have to wait for analysis for those with large staffs and specialized tools before I can render a final opinion on it.

Barack Obama is scheduled top speak on the Senate Bill at 1:30 PM EST (10:30 AM PST) about 30 minutes from now.

I expect to have a more detailed report tomorrow.

Share