Feb 112010
 

If the GOP does show up, the only thing I expect Obama to accomplish during the health care summit is to make fools of them by slicing and dicing the talking points they parrot.

healthcarenow Despite the demands of Boehner and Cantor that a reconciliation fix for healthcare refrom be ruled out, Obama is staying open to that option.

White House Spokesman Robert Gibbs said on Tuesday that Republicans coming to the West Wing for the much-anticipated February 25 meeting would be better off arriving "without preconditions." Asked whether Obama would commit to not using reconciliation — which would allow aspects of health care legislation to be considered in the Senate by an up-or-down vote — Gibbs replied: "The president is not going to eliminate things based on preconditions. And if that’s one of their preconditions, the president doesn’t agree to limiting the way we are going to discuss this."

Good thing, because healthcare reform isn’t going to happen without it. That’s pretty clear from the actions of one of those "moderate" Republicans, Susan Collins. Here’s an editorial from the Portland Press Herald on the latest from her:

Sen. Susan Collins wrote a column for this newspaper explaining her objections to the package that she voted against in the Senate on Christmas Eve. ("Cost control essential if health care reform is to succeed," Feb 1)

Collins said that she would not vote for the bill because it didn’t do enough to control costs and listed several areas in which it could be better.

One was a practice called bundling, in which providers are paid in lump sums to treat patients instead of by the service. Another was penalizing hospitals that have high infection rates.

Both are good ideas, both have support from health care economists as likely ways to cut costs while providing better care. And both, as Collins admits in her piece, are already in the Senate bill that she voted against….

As someone who wants to see comprehensive health care reform, I should be encouraged by Collins’ common sense and practical ideas that would probably make the whole package better if they were part of the law.

But Collins never said that she would vote for the "whole package." While she and other Republicans say they are waiting to engage in bipartisan talks on health insurance reform, they seem to be gaining too much politically by letting the Democrats flop around on the dock gasping for air.

As long as there is no political cost to Republicans for wasting a whole year and accomplishing nothing other than maintaining an unsustainable status quo, don’t expect them to move.

That’s why, in this case, practical, common-sense proposals are just another way of saying "no."

Since Olympia Snowe and Susan Collins are conjoined twins, don’t expect Snowe to touch bipartisanship with a ten-foot pole now. If anything approaching meaningful reform is going to happen, it’s through the reconciliation sidecar coupled with the Senate bill… [emphasis original]

Inserted from <Daily Kos>

I hope that the Democrats are ready to proceed with a reconciliation measure immediately.

Share
Feb 102010
 

In hope we never become immune to the stories of real people suffering from Big Insurance criminal abuse and from having no health coverage.  Sometimes, though the stories are so far removed from human decency that indignation is the only appropriate reaction.

Kyler PAUL AND MARIA VanNocker are filing a federal lawsuit today on behalf of their 5-year-old son, Kyler, whose insurance company, HealthAmerica, refuses to pay for the latest treatment needed to prolong his life.

The complaint raises lots of questions that I assume will be answered at trial, should it come to that. The question it won’t answer is one that’s been gnawing at me since I first wrote of Kyler’s plight in December:

How do HealthAmerica’s overlords sleep at night?

I know my own dreams would be haunted if I acted as arbitrarily, capriciously and abusively – to borrow some pointed adjectives from the complaint – as the VanNockers allege HealthAmerica has regarding their little boy.

The Harrisburg-based company’s denial of benefits to Kyler, the lawsuit claims, is the result of "a biased, self-serving misreading and misinterpretation" of everything from Kyler’s medical records to the company’s own internal documents.

HealthAmerica’s Kendall Marcocci told me yesterday that the company won’t comment on pending litigation. Center City attorney David Senoff, though, was happy to explain why he is representing the Van Nockers for free in the lawsuit.

"These companies have to be brought to the courthouse to get them to do the right thing," said Senoff, a specialist in insurance disputes. "This child needs this treatment, or else."

He didn’t need to explain what "or else" meant.

Readers may recall that Kyler has neuroblastoma, a rare, deadly childhood cancer that attacks the nervous system, creating tumors throughout his body.

He was diagnosed in 2007 and endured a year of medical treatment, with complications he barely survived. Thankfully, it knocked his cancer into remission for 12 lovely months, and he got to revel once again in the glories of childhood.

Last September, the disease came roaring back. This time, only one form of treatment, something called MIBG therapy, could help save his life.

But HealthAmerica refused to pay for the MIBG, which it considers "investigational/experimental" because there is "inadequate evidence in the peer-reviewed published clinical literature regarding its effectiveness." Nor is MIBG approved by the Food and Drug Administration, another criterion that HealthAmerica requires.

How come, then, asks the lawsuit, HealthAmerica covered not one but two prior therapies for Kyler that did not possess these supposed requirements?

In April 2008, the company approved Kyler’s use of a drug to treat a life-threatening blood-flow complication, even though the drug wasn’t FDA-approved, wasn’t manufactured in the United States and wasn’t "peer-reviewed."

However, it was the only known drug to treat Kyler’s condition, and he responded well to it. Four months later, HealthAmerica paid for another medication that wasn’t FDA-approved for neuroblastoma treatment.

Again, Kyler responded well.

So why, pray tell, is HealthAmerica playing the "experimental therapy" card in the case of the MIBG treatment Kyler now needs? Gee, money couldn’t have anything to do with the decision, could it?

In my December column, HealthAmerica’s Marcocci was emphatic that her company declined Kyler’s MIBG therapy not because of its cost but because of its experimental nature.

But that doesn’t mean MIBG is ineffective.

"It’s considered the standard of care in Europe and the United States for recurrent neuroblastoma," Kyler’s oncologist, Stephan Grupp, told me then. "It’s not an unproven treatment with no basis in medical science. Actually, the results are often very good."

Regardless of how you describe MIBG, one thing became clear last week when Paul and Maria got the results of Kyler’s latest tests to track his neuroblastoma.

The MIBG is working.

Children’s Hospital, where Kyler receives much of his care, proceeded with two rounds of MIBG therapy for Kyler – at a cost of $110,000 – despite the VanNockers’ inability to pay for it…

Inserted from <Philadelphia Daily News>

Here’s Keith Olbermann’s take on this.  His closing is particularly effective.

 

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

I have nothing but praise for the hospital that saved Kyler’s life with no guarantee of payment.  I have nothing but scorn for the insurance company death panel that denied his treatment and for the Republicans and DINOs that are blocking reform.

Meanwhile, the uninsured are still dying at a rate of several 9/11s per year.

Insurance greed 2 Since the unlikely election of Scott Brown in Massachusetts, hardly a day goes by in Washington without a torrent of speculation on what loss of a filibuster-proof majority will mean for the healthcare reform legislation that both houses have already passed. But as the president recently noted, the intense focus on the process of moving the bill over the finish line has done much to obscure the actual human stakes of the policy being debated.

Particularly striking is the near-total absence of the voices of those most acutely affected by the capriciousness of our current healthcare system, the millions who have no insurance. Despite the fact that 30 million of these folks have arguably the largest stake in the legislative outcome, they’re almost totally absent from the national conversation over its fate.

Here at The Nation, we have been working to right this in our own small way. We’ve spent the last two weeks searching for stories from the uninsured. Despite our chosen tools (Twitter and e-mail), or perhaps because of them, we received 185 responses from a diverse group of people. From recent college graduates, to struggling single parents, to recent retirees, the storytellers ranged vastly in age, background and occupation. However, a common thread held them all together: the anxiety and uncertainty that comes with being uninsured.

Many stories expressed great, unshakeable fear that one medical emergency would ruin them. "I would say my wife and I are one medical emergency away from losing everything, but actually I’ve pretty much resigned myself in my head to the reality that if I have a medical emergency I am going to die," says a used-book seller in California.

The responses included wide array of opinions and varied hopes for the future of healthcare reform, but what an overwhelming majority agreed upon was that the United States government, particularly Congress, had failed to represent them within the debate…

Inserted from <The Nation>

This article goes on to detail many of the stories mentioned.  I hope you will click through.  They are worth the read.

Share
Feb 102010
 

Isn’t it amazing how Republicans fought the stimulus tooth and nail but are handing out the money at home as though they fought to get it?

GOPgo If there’s one thing that unites the Republican Party it’s that the stimulus bill was a job-killing piece of legislation that was the worst thing in the whole entire world for the economy, right? Or maybe that’s just what unites them in public, because in private the Washington Times reports they’ve been working overtime to get their hands on job-creating stimulus cash.

Sen. Christopher S. Bond regularly railed against President Obama’s economic stimulus plan as irresponsible spending that would drive up the national debt. But behind the scenes, the Missouri Republican quietly sought more than $50 million from a federal agency for two projects in his state.

…

In a letter to Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack, Mr. Bond noted that one project applying to the USDA for stimulus money would "create jobs and ultimately spur economic opportunities."

Bond isn’t alone. Remember Joe "You Lie" Wilson?

Rep. Joe Wilson, South Carolina Republican who became famous after yelling, "You lie," during Mr. Obama’s addresses to Congress in September, voted against the stimulus. Nonetheless, Mr. Wilson elbowed his way into the rush for federal stimulus cash in a letter he sent to Mr. Vilsack on behalf of a foundation seeking funding.

"We know their endeavor will provide jobs and investment in one of the poorer sections of the Congressional District," he wrote to Mr. Vilsack in the Aug. 26, 2009, letter…

You see the pattern?…

Inserted from <Daily Kos>

Rachel Maddow took names… LOTS of names.

 

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

I knew this was going on, but the extent baffles the mind.  What hypocrites!  Every Republican in office is one Republican too many!

Share

Bwaaaack-Buk-Buk-Buk-Boehner!

 Posted by at 2:51 am  Politics
Feb 092010
 

There has been considerable discussion about Obama’s proposed health care summit, on camera, with the GOP.  I have commented here and on several other blogs that the Republicans lack the courage to go through with it.  The following is an excerpt from a letter to the White House from House GOP leaders, Boehner and Cantor:

buk-buk-boner …Assuming the President is sincere about moving forward on health care in a bipartisan way, does that mean he will agree to start over so that we can develop a bill that is truly worthy of the support and confidence of the American people?  Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius said today that the President is “absolutely not” resetting the legislative process for health care.  If the starting point for this meeting is the job-killing bills the American people have already soundly rejected, Republicans would rightly be reluctant to participate.

Assuming the President is sincere about moving forward in a bipartisan way, does that mean he has taken off the table the idea of relying solely on Democratic votes and jamming through health care reform by way of reconciliation?  As the President has noted recently, Democrats continue to hold large majorities in the House and Senate, which means they can attempt to pass a health care bill at any time through the reconciliation process.  Eliminating the possibility of reconciliation would represent an important show of good faith to Republicans and the American people.

If the President intends to present any kind of legislative proposal at this discussion, will he make it available to members of Congress and the American people at least 72 hours beforehand?  Our ability to move forward in a bipartisan way through this discussion rests on openness and transparency. 

Will the President include in this discussion congressional Democrats who have opposed the House and Senate health care bills?  This bipartisan discussion should reflect the bipartisan opposition to both the House bill and the kickbacks and sweetheart deals in the Senate bill.

GOPfriendsWill the President be inviting officials and lawmakers from the states to participate in this discussion?  As you may know, legislation has been introduced in at least 36 state legislatures, similar to the proposal just passed by the Democratic-controlled Virginia State Senate, providing that no individual may be compelled to purchase health insurance.  Additionally, governors of both parties have raised concerns about the additional costs that will be passed along to states under both the House and Senate bills.

The President has also mentioned his commitment to have “experts” participate in health care discussions.  Will the Feb. 25 discussion involve such “experts?” 

Will those experts include the actuaries at the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), who have determined that the both the House and Senate health care bill raise costs – just the opposite of their intended effect – and jeopardize seniors’ access to high-quality care by imposing massive Medicare cuts?  Will those experts include the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office, which has stated that the GOP alternative would reduce premiums by up to 10 percent?  Also, will Republicans be permitted to invite health care experts to participate? 

Finally, as you know, this is the first televised White House health care meeting involving the President since last March.  Many health care meetings of the closed-door variety have been held at the White House since then, including one last month where a sweetheart deal was worked out with union leaders.  Will the special interest groups that the Obama Administration has cut deals with be included in this televised discussion?… [emphasis original]

You can find this on the House Republican Leader website.  I refuse to provide that goose-stepper linkage.

Assuming the President is sincere is a backhanded way of saying that, if Obama does not answer ‘Yes’ to all the questions, he mist not be sincere.  Then this convoluted logic follows that, if he is not sincere, there is no basis for a meeting.  In short, these are demands to which Obama must agree, or there will be no televised meeting.

I’m not the only one who thinks so.  Consider what Keith Olbermann and Ezra Klien have to say:

 

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

Just for the sake of absurdity, lets assume that Obama were to accede to these demands.  What would happen?  The GOP would agree to only two reforms.  First, allow insurance companies to sell across state lines.  In the absence of federal regulation, only state regulation now holds insurance abuses in check, and that in some states only.  This reform would allow insurance companies to sell only in states with no regulation, thus circumventing what state regulation there is now and freeing them to commit even more abuses.  Second, they want tort reform to allow insurance companies to form networks of providers offering sub-standard care, but immune from suit for their malpractice.  This is the GOP solution.

Boehner and Cantor are asking Obama to surrender in advance of the meeting.  Were they to make these absurd demands to Harry Reid, I trust he would give-in.  But Obama will not, and the Republicans know it.  Therefore, this whole elaborate scheme is nothing but a ploy to avoid the meeting in which they would make fools of themselves on camera.

Share

Finally! A GOP Budget!!

 Posted by at 2:50 am  Politics
Feb 092010
 

The GOP was doing well as the Party of NO, but in a desperate attempt to prove that they really do have ideas, they have given us something to compare.

gopVision GOP Rep. Paul Ryan handed House Democrats the perfect wedge issue last week, and they’re going to use it.

House Democrats want to kick House Republicans where it hurts, and are exploring ways to force the minority party to take a stand on Rep. Paul Ryan’s budget "roadmap" that has become a political minefield in advance of this fall’s elections.

A Democratic leadership source told TPMDC they are considering options for turning the Ryan plan into a bill. Once that’s done the Democrats would put the bill on the floor, forcing Republicans to vote for or against a plan they don’t want to talk about.

Why is it such a minefield? Because he wants to eliminate Social Security and Medicare, and has put GOP leadership in a very difficult position: of course Republicans want to get rid of Social Security and Medicare, it’s been their raison d’etre since the programs were established. But they’re coming off of a year in which their loudest opposition to the Democrats’ healthcare reform bill was "Medicare cuts." Yglesias links to a Roll Call story:

Republican leaders bashed the Democratic health care plans for cutting more than $400 billion out of Medicare, but GOP budget hawks view controlling Medicare costs as essential to balancing the budget.

A Republican who asked to have his name withheld said the party’s leadership and rank and file aren’t ready to follow Ryan’s lead. “There’s a lot of worry that we beat the Democrats up on health care for cutting Medicare and now we’re going to turn around and do it,” the Republican said.

As Matt says, the major difference here is that the Dems had very targeted cuts aimed at whittling away at inefficiencies in Medicare, while Ryan’s budget "just goes after Medicare with a chain saw." And he’s doubling down on his plan, despite opposition in his own party.

A floor vote on Ryan’s Republican budget could be the best thing that’s happened for Democrats in months… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <Daily Kos>

That is so bad that even Baucus could not come up with a worse idea.  Demand a vote on the GOP budget!

Share

Bankster Bounces Back

 Posted by at 2:49 am  Politics
Feb 092010
 

Do you remember John Thain and his infamy?  Like fair-weather friends on payday, he’s back.

thain John Thain is getting a second chance.

CIT Group Inc., the lender that is trying to regain its former stature after almost collapsing during the financial industry crisis, said late Sunday it has hired the former Merrill Lynch & Co. CEO as its chairman and chief executive.

Thain is also trying to repair his own image. He brokered Merrill’s sale to Bank of America Corp. as the credit crisis peaked in the fall of 2008, but was forced to resign after the deal closed because of controversy over employee bonus payments and mounting losses at the investment bank.

CIT, which lends to more than 3,000 businesses including supermarkets and department stores, went through bankruptcy reorganization late last year after it failed to restructure billions of dollars in debt. It was also hurt by rising loan losses as more customers fell behind on repaying loans.

Thain, 54, is taking over a company that has seen its business shrink dramatically as customers fled. He’ll have to find a way to bring in new customers. And he’ll have to find new sources of funding because short-term lending known as commercial paper essentially disappeared during the credit crisis and has yet to revive.

Analysts say Thain’s experience makes him an ideal candidate to rebuild CIT’s business. He was able to get Merrill shareholders the best possible price for their stock in the Bank of America deal. And as CEO of the New York Stock Exchange, he expanded the stock market through a series of mergers and acquisitions.

"He’s taking on an extremely challenging situation," said Steve Hagenbuckle, managing principle of private equity fund TerraCap Partners. "If he survives and rights the ship, then I think his legacy has been written. It’s a perfect storm to come out a hero or come out a failure."

Thain took over Monday. He replaced interim CEO Peter Tobin, who will remain on CIT’s board of directors. Tobin had served as CEO since Jeffrey Peek retired Jan. 15.

Hal Reichwald, co-chair of the banking and specialty finance practice group at the law firm Manatt, Phelps & Phillips LLP, said Thain’s job will be made easier by the fact that few other lenders picked up the business the company lost as it headed toward bankruptcy.

"No institution has stepped up to challenge CIT," Reichwald said. That could be because banks are still tentative about lending.

"The marketplace needs a CIT," Reichwald said. But, he said, CIT can only be viable long-term if it finds new sources of funding.

Thain, a former president of Goldman Sachs Group Inc., might have been brought in because of his extensive connections on Wall Street. His experience in investment banking may help CIT find a new partner or even parent, Hagenbuckle said.

CIT will pay Thain an annual cash salary of $500,000. He will also receive $5.5 million in stock annually, of which $2.5 million will be subject to a one-year holding period. The remaining $3 million cannot be sold for three years.

Thain could also receive up to $1.5 million in bonuses based on the performance of the company. The board will determine whether to award the performance-based bonuses.

Thain’s deal to sell Merrill was considered a lifesaving move at the height of the financial crisis. But he was criticized for having paid out $3.6 billion in bonuses to Merrill employees just before the deal closed, and for spending more than $1 million to redecorate his office at Merrill despite its massive losses.

Thain resigned as head of global wealth management of the combined company in January 2009, after news of the bonus payments surfaced. Bank of America last week agreed to settle a case with the Securities and Exchange Commission over claims it misled shareholders about the bonuses and more than $15 billion in fourth-quarter losses at Merrill to ensure the deal would be approved… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <AP>

It seems that no matter how much these banksters fail, no matter how far their companies fall, and no matter out outrageous their abuse, they always have a multi-million dollar job waiting.

Share
Feb 082010
 

Last week, right-wing web and radio  and the GOP Reichsministry of Propaganda, Faux Noise, have been parroting a false claim in Reuters that the Obama administration has embedded hidden tax increases for most Americans in the budget.  No doubt this wing-nut media frenzy will continue, because they are counting on public ignorance of this:

Bullshit The journalist who wrote an article on Monday that turned into an embarrassment for Reuters has left the wire service, the company said Friday. A Reuters spokeswoman declined to say whether the journalist, Terri Cullen, left voluntarily, or why. “I can’t really go into any detail,” said the spokeswoman, Courtney Dolan.

Ms. Cullen stepped down less than a month after being hired for the newly created position of wealth management editor. She had worked for more than a decade for The Wall Street Journal Online.

Her article said that President Obama’s budget amounted to a backdoor tax increase for middle-income and even lower-income people, based largely on the scheduled expiration of income tax cuts passed in 2001. But the president had actually proposed keeping those cuts in place for all but high-income families. [$250,000 up]

After a complaint from the White House, Reuters withdrew the article, stating that it was inaccurate. But by then, some prominent conservatives had seized on the article, and a few — notably Rush Limbaugh — insisted that the retraction meant simply that the media were protecting the president.

Inserted from <NY Times>

Now, stripping away the diplomatic niceties, what we see is this.  A Rupert Murdoch operative from one of his propaganda outlets (WSJ) infiltrated a respectable news wire (Reuters) to plant the GOP’s favorite big lie: “Obama will raise your taxes.”  Reuters, properly chagrined, retracted the story and fired the liar.  No matter.  The damage is done.  You can be sure that Terri Cullen will resurface somewhere in Murdoch’s media empire.  I am also confident that we will have to counter this claim with the facts over and over throughout the Presidential campaign of 2012,  The only lower and middle class tax Obama has supported is the smokers tax in SCHIP.  He would have been better served to tax Big Tobacco directly.

Share

A Mooseolini Hand Job

 Posted by at 3:23 am  Politics
Feb 082010
 

In yesterday’s Open Thread, I noted that I had seen Sarah Palin, aka Mooseolini, aka Caribou Barbie, aka the Dingbat Diva, aka Snake Oil Sarah looking at her palm, as though there were crib notes on it.  It turns out that I was right.  Here’s video:

 

Now I couldn’t quite make out what was there, but I also found a close up:

palinhandclose

Closer inspection of a photo of Sarah Palin, during a speech in which she mocked President Obama for his use of a teleprompter, reveals several notes written on her left hand. The words "Energy", "Tax" and "Lift American Spirits" are clearly visible. There’s also what appears to read as "Budget cuts" with the word Budget crossed out.

Inserted from <Huffington Post>

One of the things I remember from her speech was mocking us hopey changey people for following a man that had to use a teleprompter.  I guess she figures her audience did not see him obliterate GOP representatives at their retreat with no teleprompter.  Isn’t it ironic that the only reason Moosie Woosie doesn’t use a teleprompter is that it’s too techie weckie for her.

Share