Apr 102010
 

Let me begin by thanking Justice Stevens for his many years of service to the American people.

When he was appointed by Gerald Ford, a Republican President, he was a moderate conservative.  Over the years, the Court has drifted further and further to the right, so what was a moderate conservative stance then has become very liberal by today’s standards, especially in comparison the extreme, activist ideologues on the Court: Scalia, Thomas, Alito Scalito, and Roberts.  Stevens has big shoes to fill.  Can Obama fill them?

Stevens-SCOTUS The announcement by Justice John Paul Stevens on Friday that he would retire at the end of this term gives President Obama the rare opportunity to make back-to-back appointments to the Supreme Court during the first two years of his presidency.

But it also presents Mr. Obama with a complex political challenge: getting a nominee confirmed in the thick of a midterm election season, when Republicans, fueled by the intensity of their conservative base, are angling to knock him down, and Democrats, despite having lost their 60-vote supermajority in the Senate, are eager to flex their muscles after passing a landmark health care bill.

Justice Stevens’s announcement, delivered to the White House on Friday morning in a one-paragraph letter that began “My dear Mr. President,” set off an immediate scramble among the parties and a raft of advocacy groups that have been assembling dossiers on potential successors.

The three leading candidates — Mr. Obama is considering about 10 names all told, the White House says — present the president with a spectrum of ideological reputations, government backgrounds and life experiences. His choice will shape the battle to win Senate confirmation of his nominee.

In effect, the president must choose to be bold or play it safe.

Merrick B. Garland, 58, an appeals court judge here, is well liked by elite legal advocates and is widely considered the safest choice if Mr. Obama wants to avoid a confrontation with the minority party. A former federal prosecutor who worked on the Oklahoma City bombings, he is well-known in Washington’s legal-political community, where some view him as a kind of Democratic version of Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr.

Elena Kagan, 49, is solicitor general but has never been a judge and does not have a lengthy trail of scholarly writings, so her views are less well documented. But as the dean of Harvard Law School, she earned respect across ideological lines by bringing in several high-profile conservative professors, and she is a favorite among some in the extended Obama circle, who see her as smart and capable. Her relative youth means she could shape the court for decades to come.

Diane P. Wood, 59, a federal appeals court judge in Mr. Obama’s home city, Chicago, is seen as the most liberal of the three. She has been a progressive voice on a court that is home to several heavyweight conservative intellectuals. As a divorced mother of three, she brings the kind of real-life experience that Mr. Obama considers important. But her strong support for abortion rights would provoke a confrontation with conservatives. On Friday, the anti-abortion group Americans United for Life warned that a Wood nomination “would return the abortion wars to the Supreme Court.”

In making his selection, Mr. Obama confronts a vastly altered political landscape from the one he faced just 11 months ago, when he nominated Sonia Sotomayor to fill the seat left vacant by the retirement of Justice David H. Souter.

With the election of Senator Scott Brown, Republican of Massachusetts, Democrats can no longer hold off a Republican filibuster. And while Democrats are emboldened by the health care vote, the passage of the legislation — which is already facing legal challenges from Republicans who say it is unconstitutional — has left the Senate more polarized than ever and created a climate in which the courts could easily become an election issue.

For the court, Justice Stevens’s departure will be the end of an era. He is the longest-serving justice by more than a decade, and he is the last remaining justice to have served in World War II. (He joined the Navy, where he served as a cryptographer, the day before Pearl Harbor was attacked.) His leaving will not, however, change the composition of the court; although he was appointed in 1975 by President Gerald R. Ford, a Republican, he has become one of its most reliably liberal members during his nearly 35-year tenure, as the court drifted ever rightward.

Still, for Mr. Obama, who taught constitutional law at the University of Chicago (where he was a colleague of Judge Wood), the vacancy is an unmistakable chance to put his stamp on the direction the court takes for the next several decades. Mr. Obama is already engaged in an unusual public confrontation with the court over its recent decision in the Citizens United case, which lifted strict limits on corporate spending in elections. On Friday, during a brief appearance in the Rose Garden, he made clear that the case was very much on his mind.

He vowed to “move quickly” in announcing a nominee. Senior advisers said they expected a decision within the next several weeks. The president said he would look for a candidate who possessed what he described as qualities similar to that of Justice Stevens: “an independent mind, a record of excellence and integrity, a fierce dedication to the rule of law and a keen understanding of how the law affects the daily lives of the American people.”… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <NY Times>

I consider the first two choices unacceptable.  Garland appears moderate-right, and Kagan appears moderate.  Either of them might be acceptable as a replacement for one of the right wing extremists, but not for Stevens.  Just to preserve the present imbalance we need a progressive capable of assuming Steven’s leadership role.

Wood might fill the bill.  I’ll need to investigate her background further.

Keith Olbermann and Jonathan Turley discuss Steven’s impact and potential nominees.

 

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

Unless Obama appoints someone unacceptable to progressives, a GOP Filibuster is almost certain.  Their objection is likely to focus on health care reform.

GOP2 Sen. Jeff Sessions, the ranking member of the Judiciary Committee tasked with hearings for President Obama’s Supreme Court nominee, today offered a strong hint about the direction Republicans may take toward the president’s choice.

Sessions (R-AL) used his statement to criticize Obama’s "empathy" standard for selecting Sonia Sotomayor last year for the high court.

But one sentence especially stood out: "There is much at stake, as the court’s interpretation of the Constitution in the coming years could significantly affect the implementation of domestic polices approved by the president and Congress over the past year."… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <TPM>

Rachel Maddow offered two clips worth adding.  In the first she analyzes the historical background.

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

She was certainly correct about the fundraising.  I’ve received a dozen emails already.

In the second, she and Dahlia Lithwick discuss the balance of the court.

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

Once again, unless we get a strong progressive Justice, the imbalance on the court will only be worse.

If I had the choice, who would I pick?  I’m not sure, yet.  However, a seemingly unrelated news story may be significant.

dawnjohnsen President Barack Obama’s nominee to head the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel has withdrawn her bid for confirmation, after several Republicans objected to her criticism of the Bush administration’s terrorist interrogation policies.

Dawn Johnsen’s withdrawal – a setback for the Obama administration – was announced late Friday by the White House on a day the capital’s legal and political elites were absorbed in the news that Justice John Paul Stevens would retire from the Supreme Court.

The Senate Judiciary Committee had recommended Johnsen’s confirmation on party-line votes. But several Republicans objected to her sharp criticisms of terrorist interrogation policies under President George W. Bush, and the full Senate never voted on her nomination.

The decision about who should lead the little-known office became a political flashpoint because of the controversies surrounding Bush-era interrogations of terror suspects.

During the Bush administration, lawyers at the OLC wrote memos approving interrogation techniques that human rights advocates call torture. Those methods included waterboarding, or simulated drowning.

Lawyers who worked on those legal opinions were investigated for years but ultimately the Justice Department decided their actions were the result of poor judgement, not professional misconduct.

In announcing Johnsen’s withdrawal, both she and the White House blamed what they called politically motivated opposition… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <Washington Post>

nuclear_blast I’m almost afraid to hope that the vacancy on the Court and Johnson withdrawing her name on the same day is not a coincidence.  Does Obama have sufficient courage to nominate her or someone like her?  God, I pray that he does!

The argument for appointing a moderate is that the GOP will filibuster a lefty.  In my opinion, they are likely to filibuster a moderate too.  To be sure of a smooth confirmation, Obama would have to nominate a rabid right activist.

Rather than that, there is a better alternative.  I have discussed the nuclear option before.  I’m sure I will be discussing it in detail again.  For now, I’ll just let the graphic say it.

Share

What Fox Thinks of Europeans

 Posted by at 5:27 am  Politics
Apr 102010
 

The audacity of this view matches its lack of integrity.

Fox_News_Nazi Last night, while debating raising taxes on the wealthy with radio host Mark Levine, Fox Business host Stuart Varney claimed that progressive tax policies will turn us into Europeans, who are “a pack of Pagan losers”:

VARNEY: Europe is paralyzed with debt, subject to massive entitlement programs, and riddle with anxiety. We are going down that road with our taxation policies. And once we enact a VAT, a hidden sales tax, we’ll go even further down that road. It is profoundly un-American. We’re going to resemble Europeans, who are essentially, a pack of Pagan losers. And I don’t want to go in that direction!

Watch it:

 

Varney’s claim is ironic, given the fact that the Fox Business host is British-born and a graduate of the London School of Economics. [Faux Noise delinked] It should be noted that Western Europeans enjoy a lower poverty rate, an economy nearly as large as China and the United States combined, much more generous worker benefits and vacation time, and a higher per capita GDP growth rate than the United States. [emphasis original]

Inserted from <Think Progress>

What else would we expect from the GOP Reichsministry of Propaganda?

I assure our European Readers that the bulk of Americans do not share this insanity.

Share

It’s Not Just Mine Safety

 Posted by at 5:26 am  Politics
Apr 102010
 

Years of GOP deregulation of safety standards for workers has brought us to this.

 

The nation’s attention may be focused on the mine explosion at the Upper Big Branch mine in West Virginia, but around the country, 16 people die every day from preventable injuries and accidents in the workplace.  This video from Brave New Films looks at the regulations that exist–and new regulations that would help Hilda Solis’s labor department better protect working people in the U.S.

Inserted from <Grit TV>

Every Republican in office is one republican too many.

Share
 Comments Off on It’s Not Just Mine Safety
Apr 092010
 

Ronald Reagan did few things right, but beginning nuclear arms reduction between the US and the USSR was one of them.  Assuming this treaty is ratified, almost one third of the world’s nuclear emissions will be eliminated.

 treaty

President Barack Obama and Russian President Dmitry Medvedev, signing a new nuclear arms reduction pact today in Prague, said the treaty reflects a great improvement in relations between the former Cold War enemies since Obama took office last year and called for a "reset."

Obama, speaking at the signing ceremony for the new Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty, predicted "strong, tough" sanctions against Iran for its nuclear program will come next, sometime this spring. Working together, he said, the U.S. and Russia should be able to reach an agreement with other key nations on the terms of those sanctions.

The treaty, Obama said, also demonstrates that the two countries have “stopped that drift” that occurred during the Bush administration “and proven the benefits of cooperation. Today is an important milestone for nuclear security and non-proliferation, and for U.S.-Russia relations.”

Medvedev said the treaty represents “a win-win situation."

"No one stands to lose from this agreement," Medvedev said. "I believe that this is a typical feature of our cooperation. Both parties have won. And taking into account this victory of ours, the entire world community has won.”…

Inserted from <McClatchy DC>

Old line GOP diplomats have endorsed the treaty, but there may be trouble from the GOP leadership.  Mitch ‘the filibastard’ McConnell has indicated opposition, as has Mooseolini, aka the Tweeting Tundra Twit.

Keith Olbermann and Adm. Richard Burt provided some excellent background.

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

Keith certainly called it right, when he said. “That woman is an idiot!”

Clearly the GOP is looking for any excuse to oppose this, indicating that they prefer political gamesmanship to national security.

Although there are issues over which I feel quite upset with Obama, for this he deserves high praise.

Share
Apr 092010
 

0This hydraulic fracturing study seems perfectly reasonable to me.  The EPA should do it.  Why is the Oil and Gas industry opposing it?

water A federal study of hydraulic fracturing set to begin this spring is expected to provide the most expansive look yet at how the natural gas drilling process can affect drinking water supplies, according to interviews with EPA officials and a set of documents outlining the scope of the project. The research will take a substantial step beyond previous studies and focus on how a broad range of ancillary activity – not just the act of injecting fluids under pressure – may affect drinking water quality.

The oil and gas industry strongly opposes this new approach. The agency’s intended research "goes well beyond relationships between hydraulic fracturing and drinking water," said Lee Fuller, vice president of government affairs for the Independent Petroleum Association of America in comments (PDF) he submitted to the Environmental Protection Agency.

The "lifecycle" approach will allow the agency to take into account hundreds of reports of water contamination in gas drilling fields across the country. Although the agency hasn’t settled on the exact details, researchers could examine both underground and surface water supplies, gas well construction errors, liquid waste disposal issues and chemical storage plans as part of its assessment.

The EPA begins public hearings today in Washington to nail down the scope of the study.

Plans for the study have attracted international attention and have been the focus of intense debate among lawmakers and the oil and gas industry. The findings could affect Congress’ decision whether to repeal an exemption that shields the fracturing process from federal regulation under the Safe Drinking Water Act.

The EPA is undertaking the study in response to a wave of reports of water contamination in drilling areas across the country and a Congressional mandate issued in an appropriations bill last fall. The agency had previously examined hydraulic fracturing in a 2004 study that was limited in scope and was widely criticized.

"When we did the 2004 study we were looking particularly for potential for impacts from hydraulic fracturing fluid underground to underground sources of drinking water," said Cynthia Dougherty, the EPA’s director of the Office of Ground Water and Drinking Water. "So it was a much narrower focus."

For the latest study, the EPA sent its scoping document to its Science Advisory Board asking for the group’s input in designing the fracturing study. In the document, the EPA explained that information gained from looking at the impact from the start to the end of the process, called a lifecycle assessment "can help policymakers understand and make decisions about the breadth of issues related to hydraulic fracturing, including cross-media risks and the relationship to the entire natural gas production cycle."… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <Alternet>

In order to set a better regulatory policy covering drilling for gas, we need to understand the environmental costs and risks involved in this process.  Only then can we set a policy that mandates procedures that minimize the risk of ground water contamination and procedures to repair environmental damage as part of the cost of production.  If the study discovers that the process is benign, it could result in less regulation to the oil and gas industry.

To me it seems probable that the oil and gas industry have already done sufficient research on their own, knows that they are contaminating ground water, and kept the results secret.  They do not want to bear the cost of preventing environmental damage, and they want to externalize the cost of environmental clean-up by leaving it for taxpayers.

Corporations have no consciences.  They exist only to make profit.  As we have seen that for Big Coal, profit trumps the lives and safety of miners, for Big Oil and Gas, profit trumps the need for clean water.  They cannot be trusted.  They have the GOP in their pocket.

Share
Apr 092010
 

I’m not quite sure how to react to this.

seiu In a shot across the bow of Dems, the labor powerhouse SEIU is starting a new third party in North Carolina that hopes to field its own slate of candidates, part of an effort to make the Democratic Party more reliable on issues important to labor, I’m told.

SEIU officials setting up the new party, called North Carolina First, are currently on the ground collecting signatures to qualify as a state party, SEIU officials tell me, adding that there are around 100 canvassers on the ground right now. The goal: To have the party up and running so candidates can run in this fall’s elections.

It won’t be lost on political observers that three House Dems who voted No on reform are from the state: Heath Shuler, Mike McIntyre, and Larry Kissell.

The new project is an outgrowth of SEIU’s earlier vow to hold House Dems accountable for voting against heatlh reform and against labor’s interests in general. That said, presuming the party qualifies at all, it remains to be seen how much clout it will wield.

For instance, it’s unclear which districts the party might field a candidate in, and what the criteria for picking those districts will be. A lot of these things will be determined by availability of candidates and other local political concerns…

Inserted from <The Plumline>

I’m the first to agree that these cowardly Blue Dogs are not welcome in my cathouse.  They have to go!  But is this the right way?  The political deck is so stacked against third parties that SEIU might be better served to champion opponents in the Democratic party.  If they cannot win the elections, as a third party, they will split the Democratic vote and deliver the seats to the Republicans.

Share
Apr 082010
 

Net Neutrality took a hit in the Corporate GOP DC Circuit Court.

net_neutrality Yesterday, a federal appeals court ruled that the FCC had limited authority to regulate broadband services, meaning essentially that the FCC would not have the power to enforce Net Neutrality–giving all Internet users, and all Internet content providers, equal access to the network.

The decision is a setback for Net Neutrality advocates, for the FCC, and a minor win for Comcast, which has asserted its right to slow its own cable customers’ access to file-sharing, the issue for the case. But it’s not an out and out win for Comcast, as Jack Balkin explains, because there are a number of ways forward from here for the FCC.

  1. The Supreme Court overturns the D.C. Circuit on the scope of the FCC’s ancillary jurisdiction, and the FCC goes on to fight the other issues in the case. One reason why the Supreme Court might reverse is because of its Brand X decision, in which it upheld the FCC’s decision in its 2002 Cable Modem Order to treat broadband providers not as common carriers subject to regulation under Title II of the Federal Communications Act, but rather as "information services" which would be subject to much less stringent regulations. Brand X was premised on the assumption that the FCC might still regulate broadband providers, even if they were classified as "information services" and not subject to the more stringent requirements of Title II. The D.C. Circuit has declared these parts of Brand X dicta or read them very narrowly. The Supreme Court might disagree.
  2. Congress might amend the Federal Communications Act to create a new source of jurisdiction to regulate broadband. To do this one would need at least 60 votes in the Senate. Good luck with that. Comcast and other broadband providers probably could exert influence in both parties to prevent broad new regulatory authority to the FCC.
  3. The FCC might revisit its initial decision in its 2002 Cable Modem Order to treat broadband providers as information services instead of telecommunications services (regulated by Title II of the Communications Act). The Supreme Court let the FCC classify broadband this way in the Brand X decision, but in hindsight it was a big mistake on the FCC’s part, because it put the FCC’s regulatory authority on a much shakier ground. If the FCC goes through the administrative process of reversing its earlier decision about cable broadband, and places cable and DSL under Title II authority, there is little doubt that it has jurisdictional power to impose network neutrality requirements. And it may create special rules or exemptions for broadband under Title II to the extent that the existing common carriage model of telephone service is inappropriate for broadband. Indeed, under its Title II jurisdiction, the FCC can require open access requirements, which would be even more valuable for purposes of promoting freedom of speech and innovation.

It’s possible that the FCC will simply see if it can get a reversal in the Supreme Court. That will take many more years of litigation. But the FCC might decide that the better solution is to retrace its steps, correct the mistake it made in 2002, and reassert Title II authority over broadband.  Doing this would give the FCC the tools it needs to deal with the regulatory problems of the future.

That option, the FCC reasserting its Title II authority over broadband, won’t happen without a fight, but it seems to be the best option for an FCC that under chairman Genachowski has been a strong Net Neutrality advocate… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <Daily Kos>

I don’t know what will transpire from here, so I cannot recommend a specific option yet, except that we keep a very close eye on this issue.  If the giant telecoms have their way, their corporate propaganda will travel at the speed of light, while our freedom of speech travels at the speed of mud.

Share

Greenspan on the Defensive

 Posted by at 4:04 am  Politics
Apr 082010
 

Alan Greenspan wants us to believe that he had nothing to do with the GOP recession, the worst financial collapse since the Great Depression.

alan-greenspan In testimony before the Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission, former Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan defended his record during questions by Chairman Phil Angelides by saying he was "right 70 percent" and "wrong 30 percent" of the time.

When asked whether the financial crisis was one of the times he got it wrong he answered, "I don’t know."

If there is a photo in the dictionary next to the word "clueless" it should look like Alan Greenspan.

These are outrageous statements by a financial regulator whose job was to protect the entire U.S. economy. The fact that the lead-up to the financial meltdown in 2008 happened under Greenspan’s watch seems to have escaped his grasp.

Imagine if airline pilots only landed 70 percent of airplanes, crossing guards only protected 70 percent of students or if your bank only honored 70 percent of your checks. It would be a public scandal. There would be indictments; prosecutions and surely the perpetrators would face consequences. We need the same expectation of safety for our banks that we have for airplanes flying America’s skies–that they won’t crash.

Nobody is asking anybody to predict the future, but there were other economists who saw what was happening and who didn’t have the job of protecting the public. It would seem that Greenspan had the wrong personality and outlook for the job of Federal Reserve Chairman. He acted more like "Wall Street’s man in Washington" than "the most powerful person in banking."

What we really learned from his testimony is what many already know: Alan Greenspan was and still is ideologically opposed to oversight of Big Banks and Wall Street. He didn’t take action to stem the financial crisis because he didn’t believe in action. That is the worst quality in a financial regulator. We want our sheriffs to catch the bad guys just like we want financial regulators to keep the Big Banks in line.

The failures in Washington over the last ten years–like the failures at the big banks–had two things going on: bad laws and regulators who didn’t believe they had a role to play. Both things need to change… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <Huffington Post>

I have described my recommendations for financial reform so many times to date, that today I’ll just mention two things.  Foxes do a lousy job at guarding henhouses.  Too big to fail is too big to exist.

Share