Jul 142010
 

constitution 

We have been covering the US Constitution line by line.  When Republicans wave their paper props and parrot their vile machinations, we will be prepared to expose the lies.  We have finished the main body of the Constitution.  Now we continue the Amendments.  You can find the last article on the main body of the Constitution here. It has links to all the others.  The text comes from The US Constitution.  Previous articles in the Amendment series:

Article I

 

Article [II]

A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.

There appears to be some connection between the right to bear arms and the use of those arms in a well regulated militia, which is under Presidential control per Article II, Section 2, Paragraph 1 of the Constitution.  In modern times it is the National Guard.  Private militias are not included here.  The Amendment does not state whether the right extends to gun ownership outside the militia.  Over the years, the Court has ruled that it does.  Republicans usually interpret the right as absolute.  They are wrong.  Some on the extreme left would outlaw gun ownership altogether.  I think the truth lies somewhere in the middle.

Like other rights, this one has limitations.  I don’t have the right to own a howitzer, not even a small one.  Machine gun ownership is illegal.  The question is this.  Where do we draw the line?  I think we need to strike a reasonable balance between legitimate gun ownership for sport or self-defense and irresponsible gun ownership.  Personally, I think it reasonable to license gun ownership, subject to a background check and training in gun safety, but that’s just mo own opinion.

Of one thing, I am certain.  This right does not include the Second Amendment solutions that Republicans are threatening, if they do not get their way in the upcoming elections.

Article [III]

No Soldier shall, in time of peace be quartered in any house, without the consent of the Owner, nor in time of war, but in a manner to be prescribed by law.

This Amendment is straightforward.  It is especially notable in that it and Article II are the only parts of the original Bill of Rights that Bush and the Republican party have not violated.

Share
Jul 142010
 

In a short take yesterday, I reported Kyl’s indefensible hypocrisy regarding unemployment insurance vs tax cuts for the rich.  He is not alone.

GOPhelp For weeks, Senate Republicans have filibustered an extension of unemployment benefits on the grounds that Democrats aren’t willing to cut spending or raise taxes to pay for them. At the same time, the Bush tax cuts are set to expire, and Republicans want them to be renewed. For two days, Senate Minority Whip Jon Kyl has raised eyebrows by insisting that emergency aid to unemployed people — what he called a "necessary evil" — be paid for through either tax hikes or spending cuts, while the tax cuts (which mostly benefit wealthy people) not be offset in any way. Yesterday claimed that this view is shared by "most of the people in my party."

He was correct.

"That’s been the majority Republican view for some time," Minority Leader Mitch McConnell told TPMDC this afternoon after the weekly GOP press conference. "That there’s no evidence whatsoever that the Bush tax cuts actually diminished revenue. They increased revenue, because of the vibrancy of these tax cuts in the economy. So I think what Senator Kyl was expressing was the view of virtually every Republican on that subject."

The CBO and other budget experts strongly disagree. And Democrats want to preserve the Bush tax cuts for people making less than $200,000-$250,000 a year — but only for them. Allowing them to expire for wealthier people would raise hundreds of billions of dollars over 10 years, which could allow them to offset the spending Republicans currently decry.

However, the GOP’s top budget guy, Sen. Judd Gregg (R-NH), disagrees. He said Kyl’s prescription — offset spending with tax increases or program cuts, but treat tax cuts differently — is exactly right. "It makes a lot of sense, because, you know, when you’re raising taxes you’re taking money out of peoples’ pockets," said Gregg when asked by TPMDC. "When you’re spending money, you’re spending money that is — it’s not the same thing because it’s growing the government. So I tend to think that tax cuts should not have to be offset."

The expert view is that giving unemployed people money to spend stimulates the economy much more than does preserving tax cuts for the rich. But this view is not shared by the chairman of the Republican Senate re-election committee.

"I think the urgency of deficit neutral extension of unemployment insurance has increased because of the size of the deficit and the size of the debt," Sen. John Cornyn (R-TX), another member of the GOP leadership team, told TPMDC yesterday. "I’m aware in the past some extensions have not been paid for, but if there’s one thing that I’m hearing from my constituents it’s that deficit spending has to stop, and I think this is a good place to do it."

Extending tax cuts to wealthy Americans is a different story.

"The problem is, you know, when you raise taxes, which is what that will be if no action is taken, taxes will go up on dividends and on capital gains on a whole lot of people who aren’t rich. And the problem with that in a recession is it further contracts capital formation and investment which means it has a negative impact on jobs. I really can’t think — if you really set out to try to come up with ways to discourage people from investing and creating new jobs and growing their business, I can’t think of a more comprehensive agenda for doing that than what we’ve seen over the last year and a half."… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <TPM>

This GOP position is not only irrational, but also, deceptive.  Cutting taxes for the rich has not raised revenue.  Cornyn’s is the worst lie of all.   Repealing the Bush/GOP tax cuts, as proposed, will have no effect on people making less than $250,000.  It will raise the income tax for those people from 35% to 39%.  In a nutshell, the GOP is saying that a $30 billion is too big a burden to help workers.  Many of them lost their jobs, because the GOP used taxpayer money to help corporations move those jobs overseas, and most of the rest of them lost their jobs, because the GOP trashed the economy.  At the same time they are saying that continuing a revenue drain of hundreds of billions of dollars is not too big a burden to benefit the rich!!  Here is my analysis in one word:

BULLSHIT!!

Share

The Murders on the Bridge

 Posted by at 1:43 am  Politics
Jul 142010
 

You probably remember a controversial police shooting in New Orleans killing two and wounding four as they crossed a bridge trying to escape the drowning city.  Rachel Maddow reports a recent development.

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

Bravo!  Expect the rabid right to scream bloody murder.  Would anyone care to guess the political affiliation of those officers?

Share
Jul 132010
 

constitution

We have been covering the US Constitution line by line.  When Republicans wave their paper props and parrot their vile machinations, we will be prepared to expose the lies.  We have finished the main body of the Constitution.  Now we turn to the Amendments.  You can find the last article on the main body of the Constitution here. It has links to all the others.  The text comes from The US Constitution.

Article [I]

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

This may be the most controversial sentence in US history.

The first clause provides a wall of separation between church and state.  It does not forbid people of faith from participating in government.  It does guarantee a level playing field for all faiths, including the faith that denies faith.  This is highly controversial because it contradicts Republican attempts to impose the Christian faith, through such cultural issues as prayer in schools.  They argue that, since the US was founded as a Christian nation, the founding fathers intended the establishment clause to forbid only favoring one Christian denomination over another.  That as a lie.  The founding fathers intended no such thing.  The Treaty of Tripoli specifically states, “the Government of the United States of America is not, in any sense, founded on the Christian religion”.  It was ratified in the Senate unanimously in 1797, while the founding fathers were still serving there.  Government may not provide facilities or financing to support religious activities.

Often ignored, this Amendment also forbid government to interfere with the free expression of any religion.  This is also controversial, because Republicans often attempt to prevent the religious observances of non-Christian faiths.  For example, they objected when Rep. Keith Ellison swore his oath of office on the Koran.  We are all free to practice, or not practice, faith as we see fit without interference.  Like most rights, this one does have limitations.  My rights end at the tip of your nose.  I may not practice in a way that interferes with your rights.  If I believed in human sacrifice, I would be free to hold that belief, but I could not actually sacrifice a fellow American.  Sacrificing a Canadian, on the other hand, might be OK.  I’ll have to consider that further. 😉

We are guaranteed freedom of speech.  Again it is limited.  I may not yell “FIRE!” in a crowded theatre.  I may not commit libel or slander.  I may not encourage others to commit crimes of violence against abortion providers or census workers.  I may not conspire to overthrow the US government, using Second Amendment solutions.  Nowhere does this guarantee equate money with speech.

We are guaranteed freedom of the press.  Its limits are the same as those on speech.  This freedom is central to the issue of Net Neutrality.  The Internet is the only way common people can freely publish our views without corporate censorship.  To allow corporations to block or restrict our traffic is contrary to this guarantee.

We are guaranteed the right to peaceably assemble.  Confining demonstrators to locations far from the venues at the Republican Convention of 2008 violated that right.  Demonstrators who commit acts of violence and destroy property may rightly be arrested and prosecuted for those criminal acts, but to act on the assumption that all demonstrators will act criminally is unconstitutional.

We are guaranteed the right of redress.  This right is the basis for lobbying.  Republicans interfered with this right with the K Street Project, in which they denied access to lobbyists that did not agree to donate exclusively to Republicans.

I shall try to put up a new article in this series almost every day.  It will take some time to cover it all, but when we’re done, we shall be immune to the lies with which Republicans seek to undermine our freedoms.

Share

A Lawsuit to Love

 Posted by at 3:22 am  Politics
Jul 132010
 

Do you remember the great Acorn scandal?  It turns out that there actually was some criminal activity going on.

13okeefegiles A former ACORN employee in San Diego who lost his job after being filmed giving advice to "ACORN pimp" James O’Keefe is suing the amateur videographer and his partner, Hannah Giles, San Diego CityBeat’s Dave Maass reported Friday.

Juan Carlos Vera was one of a number of ACORN employees who in the summer of 2009 was secretly filmed giving advice to O’Keefe and Giles, who told media they were posing as a pimp and prostitute with plans to bring underage prostitutes to the US from Latin America.

In a lawsuit (PDF) filed in a California court this week, Vera argues O’Keefe and Giles broke the law when they taped their conversation inside the ACORN office. California is one of about a dozen states where conversations can only be recorded if all parties to it agree. Vera is seeking $75,000, plus unspecified "special damages."

California Attorney General Jerry Brown cleared Vera of wrongdoing in a report earlier this year. Brown found that, though Vera appeared sympathetic to the "pimp and prostitute" during the taped meeting, he immediately notified the police of the conversation. Brown’s investigation also found that the O’Keefe videos were "significantly edited."

The shocking prospect of ACORN employees aiding in human trafficking prompted Congress to de-fund the group last year, a move that was later ruled unconstitutional. And a report from the Government Accountability Office, released earlier this year, found no evidence of wrongdoing on the part of ACORN, which received some $40 million in federal funding from 2005 to 2009.

In February, Hannah Giles admitted that the flamboyant pimp and prostitutes costumes in which she and O’Keefe were seen in some of the videos were never worn inside ACORN offices, contrary to most news reports. "In truth, O’Keefe represented himself to low-level ACORN workers as the college law school boyfriend of Giles, desperately trying to save her from the house of an abusive pimp who she believed would kill her," Brad Blog reported.

Vera’s lawsuit is not the first one to be launched by an ACORN employee over the O’Keefe videos. In January, Pennsylvania ACORN worker Katherine Conway-Russell sued the duo, claiming that they had misrepresented her in the videos.

"Unlike the videos [O’Keefe] has been showing on the Internet, we refused to help him and called the police and filed this report," Conway-Russell said in an ACORN-produced video.

The growing body of evidence suggesting ACORN’s wrongdoing is overblown comes too late for the organization, which announced in March it would be disbanding, due to image and financial problems… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <Raw Story>

Rachel Maddow provides some excellent background here.

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

Let’s no forget that O’Keefe is a long term GOP activist with strong ties to the party leadership.  This was not an act of a lone wing nut.  It was an orchestrated Republican scam that successfully targeted ACORN to reduce voting by minorities, the poor and the disenfranchised.  The Republican Party is devoid of honor.

Share

Republican Stimulus Hypocrisy

 Posted by at 3:22 am  Politics
Jul 132010
 

Republicans in Congress opposed Obama’s stimulus package at every turn, voted against it almost unanimously, and have continually claim it’s a failure.  Why then are they so quick to take credit for the jobs it is creating?

republican-lies House Minority Whip Rep. Eric Cantor (R-VA) has been one of the Recovery Act’s most vocal critics. After whipping his caucus into uniformly opposing the stimulus, Cantor has been the lead spokesman decrying the program as a failure. Ignoring evidence that that the stimulus is helping to turn around the economy, Cantor repeatedly says that it is “failing” to “create jobs.”

As ThinkProgress reported last year, despite his withering attacks on the stimulus, Cantor hosted two job fairs filled with employers hiring directly because of stimulus grants and programs. Tomorrow, Cantor intends to again host a job fair stimulated by jobs made possible through the Recovery Act:

– Cantor job fair employer AT&T has received two contracts totaling $837,550 from the Recovery Act.

– Cantor job fair employer Bryant & Stratton College received contracts totaling $209,571 from the Recovery Act.

– Cantor job fair employer Chesterfield County received grants totaling $406,773 from the Recovery Act.

– Cantor job fair employer CSX Transportation received grants totaling over $5.7 million from the Recovery Act.

– Cantor job fair employer Goodwill Industries International has received grants of over $6.4 million from the Recovery Act.

– Cantor job fair employer Northrop Grumman Corporation has received grants of over $2.6 million from the Recovery Act.

– Cantor job fair employer University of Richmond has received grants totaling $750,964 from the Recovery Act.

– Cantor job fair employer Nationwide Insurance has received grants totaling $25,617 from the Recovery Act.

– Cantor job fair employer United Way of Greater Richmond has received a $61,125 grant from the Recovery Act.

According to a ThinkProgress review of contracts from the Recovery.gov website, employers at the Cantor job fair tomorrow have received approximately $52,716,129 from the stimulus.

While Cantor has tried to score political points slamming the stimulus as an utter failure, he has relied on it as a crutch to bring both private and public sector jobs to his district… [emphasis original]

Inserted from <Think Progress>

We still have a long way to go with an average of over twenty applicants for every job opening.  The only reason that the stimulus isn’t doing better is that Republicans watered it down.  Nevertheless, we are far better off than we were when Obama took office and even farther better off than we would be without the stimulus.  And what are Republicans offering as an alternative?  Tax cuts for the rich, of course..

Share

End Tax Breaks for Big Oil

 Posted by at 4:33 am  Politics
Jul 122010
 

Most major industries have bought virtually all Republicans and a few Democrats to evade their fair share of the tax burden.  Big Oil have been the most successful of all.

12oil …President Obama’s 2011 budget, proposed before the spill, would eliminate $4 billion in annual tax breaks for oil and gas companies. Bills in both houses introduced after the spill would achieve many of the same results. Industry has spent $340 million on lobbying over the last two years to block these sorts of initiatives, and until recently Congress has been eager to do its bidding. This year could be different.

The White House has proposed eliminating nine tax breaks. Some are modest, all are complicated, but in toto they provide a range of cushy benefits — fast write-offs for upfront drilling expenses, generous depletion allowances, and the like — that are available at virtually every stage of the exploration and production process.

The net result, as The Times reported recently, is an effective tax rate on investment far lower than that paid by other industries. That, the Treasury Department argues, has encouraged overinvestment in oil and gas drilling at the expense of other parts of the economy.

Industry argues that these and other breaks are vital to robust domestic production and that both investment and employment would fall if they were eliminated. These arguments, which may have made sense years ago, are much less compelling when oil prices are hovering near $80 a barrel and oil companies — including BP — have been racking up huge profits.

Moreover, a Treasury Department analysis says that ending these breaks would reduce domestic production by less than 1 percent. A separate study by Congress’s Joint Economic Committee says that ending the biggest of the deductions — 9 percent of qualified income from gas and oil produced in the United States — would have zero effect on consumer prices.

Apart from these benefits, two other areas cry out for reform. One is the royalty relief program, enacted by Congress in 1995 to encourage the kind of deepwater drilling that has now landed the gulf, its wildlife and its neighboring citizens in so much trouble. Royalty rates are currently 12.5 percent of the per-barrel price for onshore leases, and up to 18.75 percent offshore.

The law suspended royalties as long as oil remained below a threshold price of $28 a barrel. Prices have long since exceeded that threshold, even adjusted for inflation; and because the law was not tightly written, companies have been able to exploit its ambiguities to save themselves billions of dollars…

…The administration also needs to look carefully at the oil industry’s use of tax havens abroad. The Senate Finance Committee has already announced that it will examine whether Transocean, the operator of the Deepwater Horizon drilling rig, exploited tax laws when it moved its headquarters first to the Cayman Islands, then to Switzerland. Other oil companies also have foreign subsidiaries; the question is whether and to what extent they use them to dodge taxes. The Times article reported that Transocean alone had saved $1.8 billion in taxes since moving overseas in 1999.

Instead of enriching the oil companies, Congress should end these unjustifiable breaks and focus on encouraging alternative fuel sources that create cleaner energy and new clean-energy jobs. [emphasis added]

Inserted from <NY Times>

The editorial staff missed what I consider the most important reason to stop subsidizing the world’s most profitable industry.  America desperately needs to move away from an oil based economy.  The industry’s inability to safeguard the environment has led to accident after accident, most recently the devastation to the Gulf of Mexico, its wetlands, and its wildlife.  Possibly even worse, we are already at the tipping point for atmospheric carbon with respect to global climate change.  Just maybe we can clean up the wetlands’ pollution from the GOP gusher, but if sea level rises three feet, what’s the point?  Subsidizing big oil is a disincentive for the development of green energy, because it makes green energy less competitive.  Isn’t that the last thing we want to do?

Share
Jul 112010
 

us-constitution

We are going to cover the Constitution and its Amendments line by line.  When Republicans wave their paper props and parrot their vile machinations, we will be prepared to expose the lies.  The text comes from The US Constitution.  It will be displayed in black, while my comments will be indented in blue.  Earlier articles include:

Preamble – Article I, Section 5
Article I, Sections 6-10
Article II, Section 1
Article II, Sections 2-4
Article III
Article IV

 

Article V

The Congress, whenever two thirds of both Houses shall deem it necessary, shall propose Amendments to this Constitution, or, on the Application of the Legislatures of two thirds of the several States, shall call a Convention for proposing Amendments, which, in either Case, shall be valid to all Intents and Purposes, as Part of this Constitution, when ratified by the Legislatures of three fourths of the several States, or by Conventions in three fourths thereof, as the one or the other Mode of Ratification may be proposed by the Congress; Provided that no Amendment which may be made prior to the Year One thousand eight hundred and eight shall in any Manner affect the first and fourth Clauses in the Ninth Section of the first Article; and that no State, without its Consent, shall be deprived of its equal Suffrage in the Senate.

The founding fathers made the Constitution possible, but difficult, to change.  It made two items unchangeable prior to 1808.  The end to the importation of slaves in 1808 was immutable.  Also any Amendment allowing direct taxes, except as imposed according to a state’s population, was forbidden prior to 1808.  It also made one provision not subject to amendment ever: all states are to be represented equally in the Senate in perpetuity.

Article VI

1:  All Debts contracted and Engagements entered into, before the Adoption of this Constitution, shall be as valid against the United States under this Constitution, as under the Confederation.

The new nation assumed the debts it had acquires on the road to independence.

2:  This Constitution, and the Laws of the United States which shall be made in Pursuance thereof; and all Treaties made, or which shall be made, under the Authority of the United States, shall be the supreme Law of the Land; and the Judges in every State shall be bound thereby, any Thing in the Constitution or Laws of any State to the Contrary notwithstanding.

The Constitution gives Treaties the same precedence as laws and even the Constitution itself.  It is interesting to note, therefore, that the Obama administration does not have the Constitutional authority to ignore our treaty obligation in Part I, Articles IV & V of the UN Convention Against Torture, which requires active prosecution of those who have authorized torture.

3:  The Senators and Representatives before mentioned, and the Members of the several State Legislatures, and all executive and judicial Officers, both of the United States and of the several States, shall be bound by Oath or Affirmation, to support this Constitution; but no religious Test shall ever be required as a Qualification to any Office or public Trust under the United States.

Considering all the Republican attacks, accusing Obama of being a Muslim, they are applying a religious test in direct contradiction to the Constitution.  In addition, Republicans during the Bush regime applied religious tests to hundreds of positions, making Jerry Falwell’s Liberty University the most common alma mater in government service.

Article VII

The Ratification of the Conventions of nine States, shall be sufficient for the Establishment of this Constitution between the States so ratifying the Same.

And so the Constitution became law.

What we have seen so far in this study is that what the Constitution says, and what Republicans are claiming it says, are completely unrelated.  To them it is only a piece of paper, to quote an infamous moron, despite their deceitful claims that they are defending it.  The believability of those lies depends on public ignorance.  Since the mainstream media have largely failed in their responsibility, the truth will remain hidden unless we make it known.

But our study is incomplete, because some of the most interesting and controversial elements of the Constitution are contained within its Amendments, so that’s where we will go from here.

I shall try to put up a new article in this series almost every day.  It will take some time to cover it all, but when we’re done, we shall be immune to the lies with which Republicans seek to undermine our freedoms.

Share