Prop 8 to SCOTUS?

 Posted by at 3:42 am  Politics
Aug 162010
 

Since the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals is the only District or Appeals Court left in the US that is not packed with extreme right wing ideologues, it is unlikely to issue a stay aqgainst the resumption of gay marriage in California.  What next?

16prop8 In all of the legal maneuvering surrounding the challenge in federal court to Proposition 8, California’s 2008 voter-approved ban on same-sex marriage, one thing has seemed all but certain: the case would eventually head to the Supreme Court.

But that trip could come — in a way — as soon as this week, as proponents of the ban seek to prevent a resumption of same-sex marriages. Judge Vaughn R. Walker of Federal District Court, who this month ruled Proposition 8 to be unconstitutional, lifted a temporary stay on his decision on Thursday, but allowed six days for a three-judge panel of the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit to review it.

Some legal experts are skeptical of whether the Ninth Circuit panel — made up of two Democratic appointees and a moderate Republican — will intervene. And so it is that proponents may find themselves heading to the Supreme Court to try to obtain an emergency stay.

It is at that level that proponents, who are on a legal losing streak, may find some relief, experts say.

Richard L. Hasen, a professor at Loyola Law School in Los Angeles who has commented extensively on the Proposition 8 trial, said the Supreme Court had been somewhat dismissive of decisions from the Ninth Circuit, particularly on “hot-button issues.”

“It’s really hard to predict what the court is going to do, but it seems in those cases that the Supreme Court is less deferential,” Mr. Hasen said.

If proponents did go to the Supreme Court, Mr. Hasen said, the justices would not be ruling on the facts or findings in the case, but on whether there was a potential harm being caused by Judge Walker’s lifting of the stay.

“A decision granting a stay would not necessarily portend a reversal on merits,” Mr. Hasen said. “It just preserves the status quo” that no same-sex marriages could be performed in California.

Going to the Supreme Court for a stay is not rare: it occurred in the Proposition 8 case in January, when supporters petitioned the court to prevent the trial from being broadcast online. That attempt was successful, with the court voting to ban streaming video from Judge Walker’s courtroom.

SafeZoneStopSign In trying to prevent same-sex marriages, however, proponents may have another hurdle, namely convincing the Circuit Court or the Supreme Court that it is their battle to fight. That is because both Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger and State Attorney General Jerry Brown — charged with upholding the state’s laws and named as defendants in the case — have repeatedly voiced opposition to Proposition 8 and have shown no interest in defending it.

“How can someone who is not covered by an injunction seek a stay for the injunction?” said Erwin Chemerinsky, the founding dean of the law school at the University of California, Irvine, who applauded Judge Walker’s decision. “It’s just such an unusual situation to be challenging the law and not have the state defending it.”

The proponents of Proposition 8 — including the organization known as Protectmarriage.com [bigots delinked], which backed the ballot measure — do have status as defendant-interveners in the case. And in an appeal to the Ninth Circuit filed on Thursday, lawyers for the defendant-interveners said they had legal standing because of “their own particularized interest in defending an initiative they have successfully sponsored.”

“California courts have repeatedly allowed proponents to intervene to defend initiatives they have sponsored,” the lawyers wrote.

That said, the conservatives on the current Supreme Court — considered to be in the majority — “have always been the most restrictive about standing,” Mr. Chemerinsky said.

“And that then makes it hard for these conservative justices, however much they disagree with Judge Walker, to find standing,” he said.

He added, “The irony here is that a doctrine that the conservatives have developed over decades restricting standing in federal cases could now be used to end the debate over Prop 8.”

Judge Walker himself addressed the issue of standing in his opinion on Thursday when he denied a request from the Proposition 8 proponents for a stay of his initial decision, issued on Aug. 4, that found the ban unconstitutional. While saying that the proponents had “organized the successful campaign for Proposition 8,” he countered that it was not their job to enforce it.

“They are not (and cannot be) responsible for the application or regulation of California marriage law,” he wrote… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <NY Times>

I first became aware of the issue of standing in this case, when Nameless brought it up with supporting links in a comment a while back, for which I thank him (her?).  Since then I have researched the matter and agree.  The proponent hate mavens have no standing in this case.  Personally, I wish they did, because Walker’s decision is not only superbly crafted, but also, based in significant part on Justice Kennedy’s precedents.  Thus, the swing vote on SCOTUS cannot easily overturn Walker’s decision without contradicting himself in the process.  I therefore predict that SCOTUS will not hear the case itself, because the fascist four, Roberts, Alito, Scalia, and Thomas, don’t want to be outvoted.  They would prefer to wait and hope that a Republican wins the Presidency in 2012, as the two most liberal Justices will be next to retire.  If the fascist four become five, gay marriage, reproductive rights, human rights, in fact, all rights except corporate rights will be in the toilet.  However, SCOTUS could conceivably rule that the proponents have standing where the stay is concerned only.  Such a ruling would be completely irrational, not to mention, unconstitutional.  But Citizens United proved that neither rational thought nor the Constitution matter to them.  So the fate of the stay remains a mystery.

Share
Aug 162010
 

Everything in this bill fits what Republicans claim to favor, so this block makes sense only one way.

16isotopes A single senator — Christopher Bond, Republican of Missouri — is blocking a bill that would ensure a reliable supply of medical isotopes while reducing the risk of nuclear terrorism. The Senate leadership needs to pry it loose.

The American Medical Isotopes Production Act has two sound objectives. It seeks to create domestic capability for making a radioisotope, molybdenum 99, whose decay products are used tens of thousands of times daily in the United States to diagnose cancer, heart disease and other ailments. There are no reactors in this country that make the isotope, so supplies have to be imported, primarily from aging reactors in Canada and Europe.

It also seeks to eliminate the use of weapons-grade uranium in making the isotopes. Foreign manufacturers obtain most of that uranium from the United States, and there is an ever-present danger that it might be diverted or stolen to make nuclear weapons.

16bond The bill would address both those problems by subsidizing domestic production of isotopes using only low-enriched uranium and by phasing out American exports of highly enriched uranium to pressure foreign suppliers to convert their reactors to use L.E.U.

The legislation has been endorsed by medical organizations that use radioisotopes and by national-security groups that worry about controlling the spread of bomb-grade materials. It was approved by the House by a thumping 400-to-17 vote in November and unanimously approved, with some amendments, by the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee in December. Then Mr. Bond, taking advantage of Senate rules, placed a “hold,” preventing floor debate and a final vote.

His rationale is weak. He favors creating domestic capacity to produce medical isotopes but warns that a ban on exports of highly enriched uranium to foreign producers could lead to shortages. The bill allows 7 to 13 years before exports would be cut off, which seems ample time to build domestic capacity and convert some foreign reactors to low-enriched uranium… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <NY Times>

Bond is not acting his own.  He clearly could not object to anything in this bill, and, as a rule, Senate Republicans won’t even fart, unless they are goose stepping in lock-step with Regime orders.  The only reasons for opposing this needed bipartisan is to prevent the passage of anything for which Democrats might take credit and to sabotage the legislative process to keep the Senate from America’s needed business.

Share
Aug 142010
 

Seventy five years ago today FDR signed the Social Security Act of 1935, passed over Republican opposition, into law.  That makes this birthday good for seniors, but some forget that unemployment insurance was part of the Social Security Act, making it good for workers too.

14rooseveltss Seventy years ago today, President Franklin Delano Roosevelt signed the law that created the Social Security system, but this year’s great debate over the program’s future has all but left behind President Bush’s goal of maintaining the system’s solvency through the baby boom’s retirement.

Instead, the battle lines have shifted to a House Republican plan to establish private investment accounts out of Social Security’s cash surplus, a plan that even its advocates say would do nothing to improve the program’s financial outlook.

Opponents of private accounts will be out in force today, with 131 events celebrating Social Security’s anniversary, including birthday balloons on the Mall and the distribution of 50,000 "birthday cards" laying out opposition to the latest version of a Social Security restructuring. On Friday, James Roosevelt kicked off events at a rally in front of his grandfather’s memorial.

Bush administration officials are also fanning out this weekend to make the case that the nation can best honor the program by accepting the president’s prescriptions for its future… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <Washington Post>

Did you notice anything unusual there?  That’s because the article is exactly five years old. Republicans were trying to prevent Social Security in 1935, were still trying to kill it in 2005, and are still trying today.  Rachel Maddow has multiple examples.

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

There were exceptions.  I was only 12 when he left office, but I liked IKE.  He was right about the stupidity of those trying to undo Social Security.  He warned us about the military-industrial complex.  Was he right about that, or what?  I hope he was right about the Republican demise as well.

Share
Aug 142010
 

Elizabeth Warren went to the White house yesterday to discuss her possible nomination to head the CFBP.  The bureau is Warren’s brain child.  It wouldn’t exist were it not for her.  She was the one who raised a stink when the original proposed finance legislation lacked consumer protection.  She has earned the job.  For Obama to appoint anyone else to the position would be both bad for America and a political disaster.

14warren Somewhere along the line, Elizabeth Warren became a symbol.

She’s either the plain-spoken, supremely smart crusader for middle-class families that her supporters adore, or she’s the power-hungry headline seeker her critics loathe, a fiery zealot disguised in professorial glasses and pastel cardigans.

But no one disputes that she’s the most prominent and polarizing candidate to lead the new Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection. The idea for an independent federal agency to protect ordinary borrowers from abuses by lenders was largely Warren’s idea, and Congress made it a reality as part of the legislation adopted last month to overhaul financial regulations. The bureau’s director will be the most powerful new banking regulator in decades and the first with the exclusive mission of focusing on consumers.

As President Obama considers whom to nominate for that role, the debate has become less about who might get the job and more about whether Warren will or won’t.

Warren met Thursday at the White House with senior Obama advisers, but a presidential spokeswoman said no decision had been made. If Obama doesn’t choose her, he risks infuriating his already-agitated liberal supporters who see Warren as the only logical candidate.

If he gives her the nod, Obama risks deepening the financial community’s distrust of his administration and sparking a confirmation fight. He would be elevating a woman who, despite her mild manner, has repeatedly proven herself a thorn in the administration’s [Geithner’s]  side during her tenure as watchdog over the government’s $700 billion bank bailout program… [emphasis added]

Pasted from <Washington Post>

Keith Olbermann and Jonathan Alter explain why Warren is actually the most confirmable candidate.

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

Obama does not need to worry about offending Wall Street Banksters.  They hate him already.  Like alter said she’s a slam dunk.  If you have not contacted the White House to request Warren’s appointment, my action alert is here.  Like Alter said, she’s a slam-dunk.  Like I have said, this is a fight we cannot afford not to have.  If Republicans want to oppose consumer protection in an election year, let them.

If Obama appoints anyone else, I shall personally organize an action campaign to filibuster the nominee.

Share

Yet Another Republican Racist

 Posted by at 1:34 am  Politics
Aug 142010
 

Everywhere we turn, Republicans are putting their racism on display.  Here’s the latest:

14pompeo Congressional candidate Mike Pompeo issued an apology Thursday to opponent Raj Goyle, saying his campaign accidentally directed Pompeo supporters to an online blog post assailing Goyle’s religion and ethnic heritage.

A Pompeo statement said his campaign office "inadvertently posted a link to a tremendously offensive blog post."

The link was posted to Pompeo’s Facebook page on Wednesday and tweeted to his Twitter followers. Campaign officials deleted the social-networking links when they realized the content of the blog post.

The post referred to Goyle, a U.S.-born citizen of Indian heritage, as "just another ‘turban topper’ we don’t need in Congress or any political office that deals with the U.S. Constitution, Christianity and the United States of America!!!"

The post was written by Bob Pinkstaff of Wichita, a retired Marine gunnery sergeant who claims the country is being invaded by Mexicans and Muslims and that only Christians should hold public office.

Pompeo and Goyle are locked in a close struggle for the 4th District congressional seat being vacated by Rep. Todd Tiahrt, R-Goddard… [emphasis added]

Inserted from <McClatchy DC>

He says it was an accident.  If such things were rare occurrences in Republican circles, I might be inclined to give him to benefit of the doubt, but when virtually every day brings several new examples of Republicans acting on racial bigotry, it has to ge one of two things: a religious dogma or a Party strategy.

Share
Aug 132010
 

The big fight brewing in Washington at the moment is whether or not and for whom to extend the Bush Tax cuts.  The Obama plan calls for extending them for everyone except the top two percent.  Republican plan include extending them for everyone, extending them for the top two percent only, and extending them for nobody, if the rich don’t get them too.  The Obama plan is the best one.  This is why.

13taxcuts This week, the Congressional Joint Committee on Taxation released an analysis of what would happen to the tax code if the Republican proposal to extend all of the Bush tax cuts were adopted. The tax cuts are scheduled to expire at the end of the year, and the Obama administration has proposed renewing only those for the lower- and middle-class.

“You will find Republicans resisting very strongly any bill that allows taxes to be raised on any segment of Americans today,” said Sen. Jon Kyl (R-AZ), while Rep. Mike Pence (R-IN) has said the House GOP will throw “everything we’ve got” into preserving the tax cuts for the wealthy. And too many Democrats — like Sens. Evan Bayh (D-IN) and Kent Conrad (D-ND) — have been cowed into expressing a willingness to extend the tax cuts temporarily for a year or two.

According to the JCT analysis, extending the cuts for the wealthy — which affect two percent of the population — for just one year will cost $36 billion. Obama’s plan, meanwhile, really focuses the tax increase at the very top of the income scale:

The biggest burden would fall on the 608,000 taxpayers who make between $500,000 and $1 million and the 315,000 who earn more than $1 million; the first group would pay $6.5 billion more, or an average of almost $10,000, and the second group would owe $31 billion more, or almost $100,000 on average, the analysis said.

That may seem like a lot, but even under Obama’s plan, the very rich will be paying less in taxes than they did in 2001, since they would be paying a lower marginal rate on their first $250,000 in income. As the New York Times noted, “taxpayers with income of more than $1 million for 2011 would still receive on average a tax cut of about $6,300 compared with what they would have paid under rates in effect until 2001.” For those earning between $250,000 and $500,000, meanwhile, the increase is “relatively low,” said Roberton Williams, an economist with the Urban Institute. “It’s less than 1 percent.”

So Obama’s plan has taxpayers still paying less than they were at the beginning of the decade, while adding $36 billion less to the deficit than the GOP’s preferred policy outcome… [emphasis original]

Inserted from <Think Progress>

Graphic Credit: Ezra Klien

Rachel Maddow and economist Austin Goolsby discuss the above chart and the tax cuts.

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

From what I understand, tax cuts to the wealthiest Americans only generate fifty cents in economic activity for every tax dollar lost to the government.  Those funds would be far more productively invested in infrastructure spending.

Republican claims that ending the tax cuts for the rich will cost US jobs is a lie.  The rich aren’t investing their money in US production.  They are investing it in Wall Street speculation and production in the Asian wage-slave markets.  Republicans want the tax cuts for the rich to continue, because the rich are the only people Republicans truly represent.  They are the party of No Millionaire Left Behind!

Share
Aug 132010
 

When  Democratic politicians lose  their spines, I often hear a groundswell of support for Dennis Kucinich.  I’m not comfortable with that, although I agree with Dennis on most issues.  When he ran for President in 2008, he said that, if nominated, he would choose Ron Paul as his running mate.  ARGH!!  Dennis!!!  How could you!!!!  For me the Eleventh Commandment is: “Thou shalt not commit Teabuggery!”  For me, this forever spoils Kucinich as a standard bearer for the progressive movement, although I shall continue to support him as a Representative.  So then, if not Kucinich, who?  I suggest Alan Grayson, a clear progressive voice.

13gibbs White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs should be fired for failing to convey President Barack Obama’s says says firebrand progressive Rep. Alan Grayson (D-FL).

Responding to a question on MSNBC Wednesday on whether he agrees with Rep. Keith Ellison (D-MN)’s call for Gibbs’ resignation, Grayson said Gibbs "shouldn’t resign, I think he should be fired."

The Florida Democrat, who became a progressive folk hero when he declared last year that the GOP health care plan amounted to hoping people "die quickly," was responding to Gibbs’ comments earlier this week that the "professional left" that is attacking Obama’s policies should be drug-tested.

"People I know have referred to him as ‘Bozo the Spokesman’," Grayson said of Gibbs. "Hes’ not conveying the value of the president’s strategies or his plans or his programs. … He’s so far in over his head, he’d have to reach up to touch his shoes."…

Inserted from <Alternet>

Here’s the video:

Is Grayson politically correct? No!  Is he diplomatic? No!  Is accurate? Yes!  Is he bold? Yes!  Does he tell it like it is?  Yes!  Is he a fighter? Yes!  In my opinion, we need a fighter, and if Grayson steps on a few toes in the process, so be it.  We need more fighters like him.

 

Share